‘The PM channels Attlee on defence. But a wealth tax, not aid cuts, should fund it’

Listening to Sir Keir Starmer explaining why standing up to Russian tyranny and bending over backward to get the United States to stay engaged in Europe is like reliving the early dramas of post-war Europe 1948-51.

Starmer’s flat, uninspiring style is almost a parody of Clement Attlee’s dull clipped upper-middle class tones as he brutally shattered the illusions of the Labour left and many British opinion formers that a post-war world based on an alliance with Moscow – the left talking with the left – could be built.

London, like Paris and other European countries have seared into institutional memory what happened when the United States went home after 1918 and Roosevelt won re-election in 1940 with this Trump like-pledge to the mothers of America: “I have said and will say again and again and again, your sons will not be sent into any foreign war.”

FDR’s pledge was welcomed in Berlin and caused despair in London. The endless babble from UK politicians about the “special relationship” a phrase coined by Winston Churchill in 1946 at the time Washington was helping dismantle the British empire based as it was on white supremacist rule but one that I never heard from American lips in years going to Washington as a British foreign minister under Tony Blair obscures the fact that US presidents are not notably pro-Brit.

Trump is far from the first president who sees the world through his own eyes

President Eisenhower shouted at Harold Macmillan during the Suez crisis: “Are you mad, Harold!” and the US pointedly refused to back Britain as London tried to hang on to its colonies.

American presidents turned a blind eye to fund-raising and weapons shipments by Irish ultra-nationalists who thought their campaign of killing children and women would prevail and did nothing to help Mrs Thatcher win the Falklands conflict.

Trump is far from the first president who sees the world through his own eyes not those of superior Brits.

And Starmer like Attlee after 1945 is very gently playing the US president as he ignores the moralistic denunciation of British bien pensants who think the UK should break relations with Washington as they watched Trump follow Vice President JD Vance into a stupid shouting match of insults with President Zelenksy who forgiveably lost his cool and tried to talk over the arrogant, cock-sure Vice President.

Zelensky quickly recovered and sent out tweets and later a speech expressing his gratitude to the United States for military, diplomatic and financial support to Ukraine since 2022.

In the same period Britain was running down its armed forces to little over 70,000 soldiers – the lowest level in nearly 300 years.

Johnson forgot the Roman adage: ‘If you want peace prepare for war.’

Boris Johnson studied classics at Oxford but forgot the Roman adage, “If you want peace prepare for war.” Britain along with France and Germany sent some military support to Ukaine but not anything like the amount of modern weapons and ammunition Ukraine needs where the US has been the main supplier.

Britain put caveats on use of its intermediate range Storm Shadow missile as Tory ministers prevented Ukraine using them to attack Putin’s bases and weapons depots just across the border in Russia.

READ MORE: Who is Baroness Chapman, the government’s new international development minister?

A year ago the Conservative government scorned President Macron when he suggested that European troops could be deployed into Ukraine but not in front-line or combat roles.

Starmer is using much more forthright language than any of the Brexit era Tory prime ministers. In this he resembles Attlee when he committed the RAF to support the Berlin Airlift in 1948-49 to face down Moscow.

But the prime minister needs to pay attention to history. When Attlee also backed Washington with troops in the Korean war, he was forced to pay for it with a reduction in health care spending much as Starmer is raiding the aid budget.

Labour is losing council by-elections

Labour is losing council by-elections and the main anti-Labour anger on doorstep is taking away the Winter Fuel Allowance on the eve of one of the coldest winters in recent memory. The Treasury save £1.4 bn with this cut. Now the Government has announced it will give the French firm Thales £1.6 bn to build new air defence missiles for the UK and for Ukraine.

75 years ago the British people could not understand why the Treasury could not raise money to ensure British health care as well as take on Russian support for North Korea. Attlee lost the subsequent election in 1951. Cutting aid whether to pensioners in the UK or the poor in the global south may feel macho and Trump-like but all it means in the poorest regions of the world is another wave of migrants heading for Britain and other rich countries as their lives become unbearable at home.

READ MORE: Starmer approval ratings leap among Labour voters amid Ukraine peace talks

In 1951, Britain was still impoverished by the war. Today UK billionaires saw their collective wealth increase last year by £35 million a day to £182 billion. There are more than 3 million milllionaires in Britain, and some Labour MPs are reported to be clamouring to tax them rather than slashing aid.

France, Germany, and Spain have imposed carefully designed solidarity taxes in their super-rich which the latter don’t really notice but which provided necessary government revenue.

In contrast to the Brexit Tory isolationist PM, let alone the increasingly ridiculous Putin fanboy, Nigel Farage and other pro-Russian Reform MPs Sir Keir Starmer has shown he is willing to lead Labour into new territory on European defence. He can risk showing the same leadership to pay for funding what needs to be done.

For more from LabourList, subscribe to our daily newsletter roundup of all things Labour – and follow us on  Bluesky, WhatsApp, Threads, X or Facebook .

• SHARE: If you have anything to share that we should be looking into or publishing about this story – or any other topic involving Labour– contact us (strictly anonymously if you wish) at [email protected].
• SUBSCRIBE: Sign up to LabourList’s morning email here for the best briefing on everything Labour, every weekday morning.
• DONATE: If you value our work, please chip in a few pounds a week and become one of our supporters, helping sustain and expand our coverage.
• PARTNER: If you or your organisation might be interested in partnering with us on sponsored events or projects, email [email protected].
• ADVERTISE: If your organisation would like to advertise or run sponsored pieces on LabourList‘s daily newsletter or website, contact our exclusive ad partners Total Politics at [email protected].