Johann Lamont suggests free university education in Scotland could end

18th December, 2012 10:09 am

In an address at the Mitchell Library in Glasgow, Scottish Labour leader Johann Lamont said that state-funded university education was “not viable” without a “serious” reduction in standards. In a wide ranging speech on education to mark her first anniversary as Scottish Labour leader, Lamont said:

“University education is costly, and faces competing claims on limited public resources.”

“Whilst it was possible to sustain a system of publicly-funded higher education in an environment of relatively low participation, this is not viable in an era of mass participation without a very serious diminution in standards and quality.”

“There is no such thing as free higher education – under a completely tax funded tuition system, everybody is forced to pay for it, including those on low incomes.”

That’ final line is not a new argument (it has been used by advocates of tuition fees in England for over a decade), but alongside Lamont’s earlier speech questioning universal benefits, it seems that the Scottish Labour leader is trying to set herself apart from the traditional position of the party in Scotland on universal, free provision.

  • Chilbaldi

    Cybernat countdown! 5…4…3…2…1…

  • AlanGiles

    Time for Lamont to join the Coaltion, perhaps?.

  • robertcp

    Depressing. I would vote SNP if I lived in Scotland.

  • Monkey_Bach

    Well, there’s a tried and tested, vote winning idea for you! Worked out really well for the Tories and the Liberal Democrats didn’t it? Eeek.

  • Michael Carey

    Is this now policy? Where was it debated and decided?

    • John Ruddy

      Can you point to the policy which she said? I cant read anywhere where she said “Students must pay fees”.

      • rekrab

        She would probably favour a return too “plural voting” but on this form she couldn’t be sure of picking up any of the two votes? Jeez!!!!

  • Amber_Star

    There’s loads of alternatives to fees, if Lamont actually wants to get Labour in a good position on this issue. I think she needs to go & meet people in the CLPs; she should make her case to them & then listen to their responses.

  • JoeDM

    Facing up to reality can sometimes be very difficult.

    • Dave Postles

      US and European universities are attracting the highest-grade performers, as repeated again in a large piece in the education section of today’s [18 October] The Guardian, the former (US Ivy League) because they have full-cost bursaries compared with the pitiable amount in the UK (which is often derogated anyway) and the latter because of the low fees (e.g. Maastricht). Even that supine class of managers, the VCs, are beginning to realise this problem of losing the highest-grade performers. The difficulty again is that young people from low-income social groups are the least likely to avail themselves of these opportunities abroad because it is not within their information field. The intimation seems to be that it is young people from public schools (in the UK sense, not the US) who are dominating these US scholarships, whilst the young people from poorer backgrounds suffer the demise of the UK HE system. No doubt many of them will avoid university altogether in the future and rely on MOOCs, another lesser experience compared with their peers from privileged backgrounds.

  • franwhi

    Why university education ?? Have tuition fees worked to widen access in England ? No !
    I don’t understand the range of this argument. Why is it so limited to certain kinds of Govt spending i.e. social spending and not aspects of defence spending and weapons procurement like Trident for example. Lets put everything on the table and decide then what our spending priorities are otherwise the attack on universal benefits seems more ideological than about savings to the public purse.

  • Redshift1

    Not impressed. The whole point is mass participation means those from low income families actually have a decent chance of going through higher education. Mass participation means that finally university funding out of general taxation is justified. Bizarre that this is the point where we decided that we should start paying fees and disappointing that Labour backed this south of the border. To now see us follow suit north of the border is even more disappointing.

    The Scandinavian countries manage free tuition. Why not us?

    Coming to a general point I’ve heard that I’ll repeat. Most scots are left of centre and pro-union. How hard can it be? Stop trying to use dividing lines with the SNP that lose us votes. They’ve cocked up over independence – why are we now trying to create our own cock up? There is no political gain in this.

    • Edward Anderson

      Mass participation has actually led to an increase in the gap between working class people like me (hello… waves) going to uni and middle class people going. The university expansion has expanded the gap between social classes as many jobs which a bright poor person could go into now need a degree which they don’t get due to a) yes, a fear of debt but mainly b) the horrific G.C.S.E results for poor students and the bad subject choices made in later education.

  • Amber_Star

    Students from low income families can’t afford the cost of the trips to the US for tests, interviews etc. And even if they scrape together the money & they succeed in those, the living costs are impossible. A full bursary is only for the fees. You have to provide a bank statement showing that you have $20k (£15k) to pay for travel, visa applications & living costs for the first year; in addition you sign a statement saying that you will provide a $20k statement each year that the bursary continues.

  • uglyfatbloke

    Oh good…another gift to the gnats. How clever is this?


  • Featured News Jeremy Corbyn announces he’s standing to be Labour leader

    Jeremy Corbyn announces he’s standing to be Labour leader

    Jeremy Corbyn has announced he is standing to be leader of the Labour Party. The Islington North MP told the Islington Tribune: “This decision to stand is in response to an overwhelming call by Labour members who want to see a broader range of candidates and a thorough debate about the future of the party. I am standing to give Labour party members a voice in this debate”. Corbyn’s announcement will please Labour members on the left of the party […]

    Read more →
  • News Sadiq Khan promises to make victims of sexual assault a priority if he’s elected as Mayor

    Sadiq Khan promises to make victims of sexual assault a priority if he’s elected as Mayor

    Sadiq Khan has said that if he is elected as Mayor, he would make the police’s response to sexual assault a priority in his first year in office. Khan, who’s one of eight people standing to be Labour’s candidate in the London Mayoral race, has explained that he would ensure there is “more specialist, trained officers, and more support for victims so they feel able to come forward.” He said that if he becomes Mayor he will make it his business […]

    Read more →
  • News Diane Abbott, London Mayoral candidate, accuses Boris Johnson of failing Londoners over toxic air

    Diane Abbott, London Mayoral candidate, accuses Boris Johnson of failing Londoners over toxic air

    Diane Abbott, one of the people in the running to be Labour’s candidate for London Mayor, has secured a debate on toxic air pollution in London. Abbott, who is the MP for Hackney North and Stoke Newington, has seen to it that the issue is debate over an-hour-and-a-half in Parliament next Tuesday. This comes as pressure mounts on Boris Johnson, current London Mayor, to look further into pollution in the capital. Johnson has said he would bring in a ultra-low emission […]

    Read more →
  • Comment It’s only right that Sure Start is emerging as a key issue in the Labour leadership contest

    It’s only right that Sure Start is emerging as a key issue in the Labour leadership contest

    Something is happening in this Labour leadership contest which has never happened before. Something really positive. Sure Start is emerging as a key issue. All four contenders have staked out strong positions on the Early Years. Yvette Cooper has promised “to lead a revolution in family support”, to introduce universal childcare and “to revive Sure Start.” Liz Kendall has argued that “having a genuine long term economic plan means prioritising the Early Years.” And she has emphasised the role of […]

    Read more →
  • News UCATT endorse Sadiq Khan to be London Mayor

    UCATT endorse Sadiq Khan to be London Mayor

    UCATT has become the latest trade union to endorse Sadiq Khan for London Mayor. UCATT represents more than 80,000 construction workers across the UK. In offering their backing to the Tooting MP they have joined GMB and Unite who last week announced they were endorsing Khan to be Labour’s candidate for London Mayor. This latest endorsement comes as Khan has laid out his plans for a ‘London Living Rent’. He is also expected to announce new policy on building more […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends