Further education is the big loser in the spending review

June 27, 2013 11:00 am

George Osborne argued that the Spending Review would promote growth and fairness. Further and higher education are key to both of these objectives: educating people to a higher level opens up opportunity and equips our economy with the higher level skills we need to compete in what the Chancellor calls ‘the global race’.

The relative ‘winner’ in today’s settlement was science and research: as our recent IPPR report proposed, the science and research budget remains ring fenced and sustained in cash terms at £4.6 billion, while the science capital budget is maintained in real terms. These are important moves, although it should be noted that accounting for inflation the budget for science will have fallen by 9% in real terms by2015 and is likely to continue to fall until 2017/18.

Osborne proclaimed today that the measures taken in the last spending review had put higher education funding on a sustainable footing.  In 2010 the government cut teaching grants to universities and replaced them with higher tuition fees, reducing the teaching grant by 50 per cent between 2012/13 and 2014/15. Of course the government is still borrowing that money and paying it out in fee loans to undergraduates – but this borrowing is ‘off the books’ and does not count towards the deficit.

One consequence of this is that it takes a huge part of government funding for universities ‘off balance sheet’, meaning that when BIS is asked to make further cuts it has relatively limited room for manoeuvre. With the research budget protected that means Vince Cable has been left making cuts to student maintenance grants. These grants are supposed to help students meet the cost of living but they are being cut by £60 million in real terms in 2015/16. Moreover there is an unallocated £45 million cut to the Hefce budget, which is likely to mean cuts in ‘widening participation’ funding that is intended to improve access to those from disadvantaged backgrounds. These decisions will become even harder after the election: IPPR calculates that BIS can expect to see a further cut of 22% to its budget in the next parliament.

Contrary to what Osborne the student finance system is not actually financially sustainable. The government has consistently over estimated how much money it will get back from graduates once they have started to repay. Rather than the 30% of loans not being repaid the government first calculated, we calculate that as much as 40% of student loans will go unpaid. IPPR estimates that this could produce a £1 billion black hole in the department’s budget over time.

The government is right to abolish the National Scholarship Programme, which is spent on fee waivers and bursaries which have proven ineffective at improving access.  £50 million of this £150 million scheme is to be switched to support disadvantaged postgraduate students. This is welcome, but the government should go further and give postgraduates access to the same subsidized loans as undergraduates. The long term cost of this to the taxpayer is very low.

The big loser in today’s announcement is further education, whose funding will be reduced by a further £260 million in 2015/16. Overall further education is taking a bigger cut than higher education, despite its vital role in improving social mobility. Coming after previous cuts to the EMA and the scrapping of the Future Jobs Fund, this government has overseen a massive withdrawal of support for those young people in education and training who do not go to university.

Rick Muir is Associate Director at IPPR

Latest

  • News Don’t underestimate Ed Miliband, David Davis warns Tories

    Don’t underestimate Ed Miliband, David Davis warns Tories

    David Davis has sent out a warning to his Conservative colleagues to underestimate Labour leader Ed Miliband at their peril. The Tory backbencher, who was beaten to the leadership in 2005 by David Cameron, told the Hull Daily Mail that just because “the media don’t like him” doesn’t mean Miliband won’t end up prime minister next year. “The media don’t like him and that translates into people picking up the same attitude. But I’m not as disparaging about Miliband as […]

    Read more →
  • News De Piero: Tories may outspend us, but we’ll out-campaign them

    De Piero: Tories may outspend us, but we’ll out-campaign them

    This week’s fundraising figures may show that the Conservatives will be able to outspend Labour in the run up to next year’s general election, but a fall in Tory membership means that we’ll be able to “out-body” them, according to Gloria De Piero. In an interview with The Guardian today, the Shadow Women and Equalities Minister explains how she is launching a campaign to connect with disengaged voters. Along with Deputy Chair of the Labour Party Jon Ashworth, De Piero […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Poll finds half of voters would pay more tax to fund NHS

    Poll finds half of voters would pay more tax to fund NHS

    Almost half of all voters would be willing to pay more tax if it meant funding the NHS, a new poll has found.   According to the ComRes survey in today’s Guardian, 49% of people would pay more if the money was going directly to the health service, while only 33% are opposed to the idea. 18% said they did not know. This is not the first indication that the general public are open to the idea of tax rises if […]

    Read more →
  • Comment The case for intervention: the Labour Party needs to find its feet in the post-Iraq era

    The case for intervention: the Labour Party needs to find its feet in the post-Iraq era

    In the decade since the invasion of Iraq many liberal societies have struggled with its legacy and how to move forward with foreign policy. The international community faces it’s next significant challenge; Isis, Kurdistan and Iraq. However, I cannot agree with Maya Goodfellow’s piece from earlier this week. To say that the foreign policy position of previous Labour governments has ‘put far too many peoples’ party membership cards at serious risk’ is not a good enough reason to allow hundreds of […]

    Read more →
  • News Tory ministers urge Osborne to cap rail fare rises

    Tory ministers urge Osborne to cap rail fare rises

    The Evening Standard have reported that high-level Tory minister are pressuring Chancellor George Osborne to cap average rail fare increases next year so that they don’t exceed inflation. In January, fail fares could rise up to nine times more than the average wage increase. It seems many Tories are worried that public discontent over such rapidly rising rail prices could manifest itself at the general election in May. In response, Patrick McLoughlin Secretary of State for Transport will allegedly lobby […]

    Read more →