Margaret Hodge for London Mayor?

11th July, 2013 12:21 pm

I’ve just finished recording the Guardian Politics podcast – which will be on their website later – during which Polly Toynbee said that she thought Margaret Hodge might throw her hat into the ring for Mayor of London. It’s a rumour I’ve heard a few times this week myself, and it certainly seems like the combative PAC Chair is considering a run at the role. But it could be a crowded field.

And of course that selection contest will now be an open primary following Ed Miliband’s speech on Tuesday – something that Sadiq Khan (a potential mayoral candidate and Shadow Minister for London) was quick to welcome.

Other names mooted in the past have included David Lammy, Jon Cruddas, Oona King,Stella Creasy, Diane Abbott and of course, Eddie Izzard. Alan Johnson has ruled himself out of the running, whilst Transport expert Christian Wolmar has already announced his candidacy.

  • Ash McGregor

    Surprised not to see Tessa Jowell, Ken Livingstone or Sir Robin Wales on that list of potentials too

    • RAnjeh

      Tessa Jowell could have been a good choice for 2012 Mayoral Candidate especially because of the Olympics. Sir Robin Wales should go to the Lords.

  • Robbie Scott

    Margret would be welcome and i think it’s a great shame that somebody as talented as her didn’t get into the cabinet.

    • RAnjeh

      Agreed. She would have been good especially in Tony Blair’s Cabinet.

    • Matthew Blott

      I agree. Looking at the candidate list she looks head and shoulders above the rest – although that isn’t saying too much, there isn’t any obviously outstanding candidate. Jon Cruddas would be acceptable but I’m not sure he has enough support. Stella Creasy lacks a big enough profile and I’m not sure David Lammy is really up to it. Eddie Izzard is a nice bloke and I’d have no problem with him being mayor but luvvies turn off as many voters as they attract. It’s a shame some here are commenting about Hodge’s age. I prefer someone with a bit of mileage compared with young spotty party apparatchiks that form too much of the political class these days.

      • Robbie Scott

        David Lammy not being up to it ? Lots of people make comments like that about him and im not sure why? Unlike any of the other candidates he used to be on the GLA so that would give him a huge advantage as Mayor as he’d know where all the levers were. The reason i ask is he’s got a ridiculously strong academic background and he performed excellently during the riots and was the voice of London almost with Boris on holiday.

        • dave stone

          “he performed excellently during the riots ”

          Goodness, I never thought I’d live to see the day…

          Lammy made a fool out of himself when he blamed the riots on Labour’s “anti-smacking law”.

          • Robbie Scott

            You’re not speaking to the issue he’s talking about discipline. It’s really easy to focus in on smacking to say the whole article is silly. The media coverage was very good for him irrespective of the policy minutia you’ve highlighted.

            They’re talking about the softly softly approach which was encouraged during that period. Many parents felt abandoned and essentially left to rot. Had they put their teens into care we’d have to foot that bill.

            I’m not a David cheerleader, lots of people are dismissive of him and point out that he never got a serious ministerial post under Blair and Brown etc. I just wondered why people had that view that’s all.

          • dave stone

            His prospects would be significantly enhanced if he included this on his campaign literature: “never got a serious ministerial post under Blair and Brown.”

          • Mike Homfray

            Even though my politics are to the left of his I actually think he would make a really effective candidate.

            And this is London – and I do think there is a case for saying a candidate from the BME community would be good. In terms of being a figurehead, which is to a large extent what the job is about.

          • Robbie Scott

            Well if there’s an open primary with Lammy or Kahn on the ticket they’ll do extremely well for that reason. 90% of BME people vote Labour if you can get them to register then a BME candidate is likely to do very well.

          • dave stone

            Siobhan Benita has been tweeting very favourably on Ed Miliband lately and, as a non-establishment figure, she would probably romp it on a Labour ticket.

            Benita has said she’ll stand again and, given the deserved loss in trust in mainstream parties, is likely to be a major force.

            But it’s best to expect the unexpected. Now that Labour has thrown in the towel on opposition to Tory austerity a growing number of austerity discontents/victims/foodbank users etc. are without a mainstream political voice.

            Certainly, dangerous times lie ahead. An equivalent to Italy’s Five Star movement could easily emerge – which may be characterised by Left or Right politics.

          • Robbie Scott

            Don’t think she’d ever get onto a Labour panel and i don’t think members would want her on a panel in 2016. All this talk of primaries is all very well and good but unless the party machine shortlist you, you’re wasting your time.

            Last time around it was Oona V Ken, I think i’m right in saying that nobody else stood. There will be a lot of Labour talent going for selection this time around from both wings of the party and i don’t think a outsider will get a look in or anybody remotely interesting.

            I don’t really agree with your point about apathy, turn out was good in 2012 and people still went for the main two parties and even pushed the greens up to third.

            I’m not in favour of primaries but if we’re going to have them for Mayor then i think we ought to have them for GLA members and certainly the top up list I think that would certainly spice things up.

          • Matthew Blott

            I agree with you there – lack of discipline is definitely a problem that the left have a problem grasping.

        • Matthew Blott

          I didn’t say he wasn’t up to it I said I wasn’t sure. I suppose that’s mainly based on the fact he’s been around a while and never really done much as far as I can see despite great things being expected of him (he was unfortunate to be cursed with “Britain’s first black prime minister” tag). I might be persuaded otherwise and I didn’t mean to pick him out – quite a few of them are underwhelming and they all have negatives. I’m not sure a good academic background qualifies someone – isn’t that part of the problem, no real life experience?

          • Robbie Scott

            Ah , I hear that a lot about Lammy and it’s true I suppose. I think your spot on with “Britain’s first black prime minister” the spot light was on him and he isn’t a performer. In contrast to Chuka who is a bit of a media darling. But i’m not sure he’s as good on policy though when he’s pushed.

            I don’t think ‘real life experience’ is hugely important for such a strategic job. It’s important if your PM or an MP but a Mayor or council leader actually requires somebody with a strategic ability and academic level thinking.

            You don’t need a degree Ken didn’t have one but he could operate at a postgraduate level and i think that’s extremely important. Real life experience is good when you’re required to exercise judgment and i think it’s more important for a Mayor to have policy expertise than be grounded.

  • dave stone

    Hodge’s ‘Britons First’ call re social housing, for which she was presented with a bouquet by the BNP, should go down a treat in the city that is said to be the most diverse in the world.

    A sensible alternative view is offered by respected anti-racist campaigners Hope not Hate:

  • george

    hang on … is this the same hodge that seems to be pretty evasive about her families tax situation at a time when virtually anyone with an ISA is being tarred as a tax criminal?

    • JoeDM

      Her tax affairs will be all over the front page of the Standard.

  • AlanGiles

    This will sound ungallant, but Ms. Hodge will be 72 by the time of the next Mayoral Election. If she served two terms, as most would-be mayors aspire to do, she would be 80 on leaving office.

    As we have to get down with the kids so much these days, would a candidate over 70 go down with the young voters, and the trendies in their Dockside lofts?.

    As far as I recall the alleged comedian Mr Ezzard has pencilled himself for 2020.

    I would think Cruddas is too busy to worry about 2016 at the moment, considering he still has the best part of two years to chisel out his tablets of stone for the “review”.
    I’d be happy with Diane Abbott, but I suspect the right wing Labourites wouldn’t be and they might do to her what they did to Ken Livingstone.

    AG 11/7/13 1438BST

    • Matthew Blott

      You’re right. It does sound ungallant.

  • S&A

    That will mean another four years of London being under Tory rule, then.
    She will be absolutely savaged because of her hypocrisy on tax.

  • rekrab

    If I were a Londoner, I’d be saying stop playing the Jerusalem card, what happened to Ken was disgraceful. Are you reading Rob?

  • simon1970

    Hodge’s time as leader of Islington Council is what will stop this from happening.

  • James P

    Does politics really need another millionaire?

  • dave stone

    It’s got to be Margaret Hodge or Oona KIng – either would work wonders for the campaign of any People before Profit/anti-machine politics candidate who might stand.

  • charles.ward

    Well it would continue the tradition of tax hypocrisy started by the previous Labour candidate. Perhaps the national party can advise her on the most tax efficient way to receive donations to her campaign.

  • Penfold

    Will she Nicky Gavron as an advisor ?

  • mattwardman

    What about Polly?

  • RAnjeh

    Atma Singh is also planning to stand..

  • PaulHalsall

    Bring back Ken.

    • Matthew Blott


    • S&A

      Yeah, that’s an awesome idea. Why don’t we dust of the 1983 election manifesto and update it for 2015 as well? We could also ask Derek Hatton if he wants to come back into politics just to make Labour’s prospects even brighter …

  • Matthew Blott

    Ken Livingstone said the last contest was the last time he’d stand for election.

    • jaime taurosangastre candelas

      He is wise. I think the reality is that he realised that it is was the last election that anyone could stand him running in.

    • Ash McGregor

      And then he stood for NEC 😉

  • Alexwilliamz

    Surely the perfect opportunity for a certain milliband to move back into the political circus?

    • Carolekins


  • Daniel Speight

    What if UKIP find a celebrity to stand? The above list doesn’t look like it could withstand a Boris-like personality.

  • The Laughing Cavalier

    Islington Children’s Homes. Enough said.


  • Featured News Labour release results of member consultation on Syria

    Labour release results of member consultation on Syria

    Labour have released the findings of their policy consultation on intervention in Syria with members over the weekend – claiming it shows 75% are opposed to airstrikes against ISIS. Jeremy Corbyn sent out an email on Friday evening to members and supporters asking for their opinion on how Labour should approach the Government’s proposals for intervention in Syria. The party have today said that 107,875 people responded to the consultation, of which 64,771 were confirmed as full Labour Party members. Of those 65,000 […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Uncategorized McMahon gains Momentum in Oldham

    McMahon gains Momentum in Oldham

    @PeoplesMomentum London thanks so much for campaigning today and throughout the campaign #IbackJim — Jim McMahon OBE (@CllrJimMcMahon) November 28, 2015 Winds of change are blowing through the Labour Party. According to some, it’s a storm blowing the party into dangerous, choppy waters. But, this past weekend in Oldham, amidst real, rather than metaphorical, strong wind (and heavy rain), a different way to harness this great gust for the common good was in evidence. On Saturday, Momentum, the grassroots […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Corbyn writes to NEC in search of backing over Syria

    Corbyn writes to NEC in search of backing over Syria

    UPDATE 13.09: There was a move to try and call an emergency NEC meeting this morning, which was hastily abandoned after it was clear that there would not be enough member present to reach a quorum. The Shadow Cabinet meeting, which had been scheduled for 1pm, has now been pushed back to 2pm – before the Parliamentary Labour Party meet at 6. Jeremy Corbyn has written to members of Labour’s National Executive Committee asking for their opinion on the party’s position […]

    Read more →
  • Europe Featured News The full list of Labour MPs signed up to pro-EU campaign

    The full list of Labour MPs signed up to pro-EU campaign

    213 MPs have signed up to Labour’s pro-EU group ‘Labour In’, including Jeremy Corbyn and the entire Shadow Cabinet. Today, Phil Wilson MP has outlined the group’s stance in an article on LabourList, saying the party is united in its “belief that Britain should remain part of the European Union”. “Our campaign will be distinctive from the cross-party campaign, because we will focus on the issues important to Labour supporters and voters, in particular economic growth, jobs and rights for […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Europe Featured Labour is united in its belief that Britain should remain part of the EU

    Labour is united in its belief that Britain should remain part of the EU

    Over 210 Labour MPs have joined the Labour In PLP group, including the Leader of the Labour Party, and the entire Shadow Cabinet. The Parliamentary Labour Party is united in its belief that Britain should remain part of the European Union. The EU referendum poses the most important question to face the UK, not just in this Parliament, but for decades to come. If we believe Britain is a force for good in the world, we must be optimistic, outward-looking […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends