Jim Messina is a superb hire for the Tories – I wish Labour had hired him

August 2, 2013 5:25 pm

The news that Obama’s 2012 Campaign Manager Jim Messina will be advising the Tories on the 2015 election campaign is a blow. Whilst US political campaigns are markedly different to their British alternatives – not least because there’s precious little money in British politics compared to America – I’m sure he will use impressive political and campaigning nous to the benefit of the Tories between now and 2015.

The odds of Labour winning the next election just got a little longer.

Evidently there’s an element of “gun for hire” about Messina going to work for the Tories. Obama’s Democrats have little in common with Cameron’s Tories – especially on the key electoral issue of the economy, where Obama went for a stimulus and Cameron went for austerity. But it’s somewhat painful to see that a senior Democrat – albeit one who is to the right of the Labour Party – thinks that the Tories are the right horse to back in 2015.

Jim Messina is a superb hire for the Tories – I wish Labour had hired him.

But what’s depressing is the contrast between how the Tories and Labour are approaching general election planning. Whilst the Tories are assiduously searching the globe for the most effective political consultants money can buy – regardless of party affiliation – Ed Miliband still hasn’t appointed a replacement for Tom Watson (one of the few Labour politicians who is a strategic campaigner). At the moment it looks worryingly like Miliband is trying to decide which one of his mates from the Shadow Cabinet to appoint to run the General Election campaign.

The real fear is that Labour will fudge the issue and have the General Election campaign run by committee – a recipe for total message ill-discipline and strategic disaster.

Perhaps it’s time to consider whether or not having a General Election campaign run by a politician is realistic. It’s beginning to look remarkably homsepun that whilst the other parties bring in professionals with a track record of running election campaigns around the world, the bar for what is considered “campaign management experience” in the Labour Party is embarrassingly low. Even the Lib Dems have their own overseas campaign whizz Ryan Coetzee. The Labour Party had made a great start, hiring the excellent Matthew McGregor fresh out of the Obama campaign to steer the party’s digital output, but other Obama campaign veterans who might have come to work for Labour have failed to materialise.

There is very little time to go until the next election. Time spent considering which politician should be running the election campaign is time wasted. Labour should – money permitting – be trying to hire the best political campaigners available to run our election campaign. If the Tories have hired Jim Messina, then Labour could do much worse than approaching David Axelrod – who has recently left the White House – to run a professional, experienced campaign for Downing Street.

The Tories now have Lynton Crosby and Jim Messina – Darth Vader and Anakin Skywalker, if you will. Who do we have? At the moment. No-one. And that’s starting to look complacent at best and embarrassing at worst.

  • RogerMcC

    What the bassist from Buffalo Springfield?

    Labour should just hire Neil Young in response.

  • RogerMcC

    And you really do miss the point about the Dems who are mainly distinguished from the Republicans not on the economy – both US parties are privatising neoliberals (and even the GOP are only opposed to a stimulus when a Democrat is doing it) – but on cultural issues (i.e. guns, gays and Jesus).

    And as gun toting homo-hating creationists are actually not a significant segment of the UK electorate a Republican strategist whose expertise is in stirring up Cletus the Slack-Jawed Yokel against latte-sipping liberal metropolitan elites would be largely useless to the Tories.

    And US political skills do not always translate well to the UK – Gordon Brown going to considerable expense to hire the likes of Bob Shrum and Stan Greenberg didn’t actually help us very much.

    • Theo Blackwell

      Only to a point, but not much further – the Democrats approach austerity with a massive stimulus and senators/states/gvt have consistently pursued tougher regulation on the financial sector than anything proposed in the UK.

      American politics is much more nuanced and varied than you make out.

      • RogerMcC

        Of course it is.

        However it is all too easy to mistake rhetoric for reality.

        Obama only had the power to fund a stimulus of any sort for 2 years and even then was forced to accept a smaller one than was required despite having supposed control of Congress as right wing Democrats failed to support him.

        Since 2010 he has little real power over the economy and is likely to have no more in 2012-16.

        And consequently he has while continuing to talk stimulus allowed the sequestration process to impose austerity.

        So ideologically as privatising, free marketeering, neo-liberals with no great interest in regulating what people do with their genitals a mainstream Obama/Clinton Democrat really does have more in common with a Tory like Cameron than with any European social-democrat.

        And that they are still very much the lesser evil is one of the more terrifying things about the planet, .

    • http://nhsvault.blogspot.com Richard Blogger

      Fully agree. Throughout the first and second Obama campaigns I’ve had a detail commentary from US friends and I’ve always thought “that could not happen here”. The US has a different approach to community than we do, sometimes Americans can be a lot more collectivist that we can be. For example, Town Hall meetings actually mean something in the US. Here, they are damp squibs: the public just are not interested.

      • Mike Homfray

        Yes – its the pluralist tradition – sociologists and political scientists will know this well. Its really not a very good fit with UK society which actually is largely disinterested in grassroots collectivism without the state – try recruiting volunteers for anything…..

  • Mike Homfray

    One of my American friends thinks that all the British political parties are Democrats and that the Republicans are way to the right of our mainstream

    • RogerMcC

      Which is an excellent way of putting it.

  • Chilbaldi

    “Whilst the Tories are assiduously searching the globe for the most
    effective political consultants money can buy – regardless of party

    The Democrats are perfectly compatible with the Tories. A lot of Labour members seem unaware of this.

    • http://nhsvault.blogspot.com Richard Blogger

      Indeed. Simon Burns, transport minister, went to the US to campaign for Obama’s presidential bid. Just because the Democrats are to the left of the GOP does not mean that they are a natural fit with Labour. US politics is much more right-wing than European politics.

  • Monkey_Bach

    No matter how clever, ingenious, or hard working a person might be they still can’t polish a turd and make it shine. We currently have a government where families with disabled children might end up evicted after their housing benefit gets cut because they have a spare bedroom. If Labour cannot defeat the worst Tory mastered government led by the worst Tory Prime Minister in living memory then there is no hope. Crosby and Messina are not political alchemists: they’re not magicians: they can’t change base metal into gold.

    And the current government is very base.

    Very base indeed.


  • Pingback: Quote of the Day - Guy Fawkes' blog

  • http://www.facebook.com/matthew.blott Matthew Blott

    I watched the report about this on Newsnight and the consensus was that Jim Messina’s appointment likely went ahead with Obama’s blessing. If true that’s a pretty sobering thought. Jim Messina has a faultless record (no election he has worked on has ever been lost) and it’s possible the Obama administration doesn’t think the stock in Miliband is worth investing in.

    Doubtless many on the left won’t believe Obama and Cameron could have a fondness for each other but that just illustrates something that can be a problem with some of my comrades – they think tribally and discount the importance of personality. I can certainly believe Obama would prefer working with Cameron to Gordon Brown and having done so for three years it’s possible he’d like to see it continue. It’s worth pointing out that Cameron has stated an intention for a post election in / out EU referendum which Obama wants Cameron to win. It may be he will call in this favour come the time.

    • Monkey_Bach

      This sounds a little fanciful to me.

      Jim Messina is only 44 years old and has, as far as I know, only worked for Democrat politicians. His involvement in helping to get Democrat Presidents elected to office could only therefore have happened in respect to Barack Obama election and re-election in 2008 and 2012.

      American citizens can only be elected to the office of President twice in their lifetimes and thus Barack Obama will be out of office by 9th November 2016 whatever happens between now and then. Whoever becomes British Prime Minister in May 2015, assuming the Coalition hangs together, will hence have slightly less than six months to work with the current President of the United States before Obama necessarily has to bow out and step down. I doubt if Obama is much exercised about who become the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, especially considering that his successor is quite likely going to be a politician selected from amongst his opponents in the Republican Party.

      I have lived in America and felt more of a foreigner there than I did in any non-English speaking European country. America really isn’t that much like the United Kingdom and I doubt very much if political methods and strategies that work in the United States will work here as well or at all.

      I am afraid that having next to no good or positive news to trumpet the Conservatives are really going to get down into the gutter and run a vicious campaign full of half-truths, character assassination, and vilification of helpless minorities to try to whip up a climate of fear and loathing they hope to exploit to their advantage.

      It’s all they have left to pull out of the bag.

      Brace yourselves!



  • leslie48

    The main reason the Tories are doing probably better than they should be( although behind Lab in opinion polls ) is indeed down to their propaganda and communication experts who are able to spin crude and divisive messages which Tory M.P.s articulate in the media. With an increasing Right Wing press, Labour needs experts too. Your concerns are spot on.

    • rekrab

      Come on Leslie48, lets face the facts, it was new labour fault that the NHS is in such a mess, they started the privatisation and those 13 years of new labour didn’t do much to improve Britain’s industry might.At the end of the day Leslie, it’s the state of the country which matters, the tories have simply used 13 years of poor new labour government to make a bad situation more horrible and labour still hasn’t any answers to what they’d do differently.

      • leslie48

        i can hardly reply to such a silly reply – but in the 2000s we had a good economy compared to Europe with very low unemployment, low inflation, growth levels, education and hi-tech expansion on an unprecedented scale esp. at 18+, the NHS improved & reduced its queues esp,. cancer appointments, more regional investment and autonomy, less child poverty.., less crime, no riots, etc., lass social divisions. Our Labour party won three elections. Of course there were imperfections; that’s life, that’s history. Grow up.

  • Monkey_Bach

    Trouble is the bust happened EVERYWHERE in the western world. The major mistake Brown made was to stupidly follow the inherently faulty neo-liberal, laissez-faire, model of capitalism pioneered by free-wheeling America during the Bush years. As far as Britain goes we’re not yet actually recovering at all. Hence Osborne, tearing his hair out panicking for some growth in the economy, has begun interfering with our already massively over-inflated housing market via government underwritten financial backing to under-capitalised first time buyers to allow them to purchase a property they really cannot afford. This could well trigger another house price bubble which, when it goes pop, will end up disastrously to lenders and borrowers alike: when interest rates begin to rise, which they absolutely will have to do over the next few years, any tentative recovery that might be happening against the odds could be extinguished overnight.


  • Monkey_Bach

    The Solution
    by Bertolt Brecht

    After the uprising of the 17th June
    The Secretary of the Writers Union
    Had leaflets distributed in the Stalinallee
    Stating that the people
    Had forfeited the confidence of the government
    And could win it back only
    By redoubled efforts. Would it not be easier
    In that case for the government
    To dissolve the people
    And elect another?

    Perhaps it would be simpler if the political classes periodically elected a people rather than submitting themselves to be elected to office themselves by an ill educated and poorly informed population of voters the political classes obviously have little connection with and a scarcely disguised lip-curling contempt toward.

    They know best after all.


  • Mike Homfray

    I simply think he has taken a job. I doubt whether deep ideological commitment has anything very much to do with it.
    Messina’s record is as someone on the right of the Democrats, and in US terms, all our parties are one sort of Democrat or another. The blend of religiously inspired social conservatism, economic neoliberalism, and localist pork-barrelling that makes up the republican party doesn’t really have an echo here. Whereas there are elements of the Democrats that fit quite well with Labour and Conservative. For example, the Democrats are effectively an economically right-wing pro-market party, but believe in big government projects in order to do so. Both our main parties would be seen as socially liberal in the US. They support abortion, gay equality, easy divorce etc.

  • swatnan

    What about Peter Mandelson? The Party will really come of age when it learns to love Peter Mandelson.

  • Monkey_Bach

    That is true but wouldn’t be happening if the Coalition had not changed the law and encouraged this atrocity to happen. Housing Associations and Councils will all eventually have to toe the line, or break the law of the land, or use some other ruse to evade mass evicting of their poorest tenants. In a front page article in today’s Independent the Bedroom Tax is attacked because 96% of people hit by reductions in their Housing Benefit because they happen to have one (or more) spare rooms cannot downsize because there is nowhere for them to go.


    This is a new kind of injustice and cruelty for which the Tories and Liberal Democrats are wholly to blame.


  • http://blessayfromamerica.blogspot.com/ Guy Bailey

    Offer David Axelrod a Lordship and get him in

  • http://blessayfromamerica.blogspot.com/ Guy Bailey

    I’m not Mandelson fan but turning a looming catastrophe into a mere defeat was a result


  • Featured Axelrod understands the importance of grassroots campaigning

    Axelrod understands the importance of grassroots campaigning

    Reading some of the coverage of David Axelrod’s appointment to advise Labour’s General Election campaign you would get the impression that grassroots campaigning was invented in the USA by the Obama campaign and had never been tried before in a British election. Sadly this is rather typical of the way the British media reports election campaigns. Journalists understand the bit of the campaign – the “air war” – which is about their world of messaging and interviews and image. They […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Axelrod – that’s what I call a reality check

    Axelrod – that’s what I call a reality check

    “It will be me.” That was Hillary Clinton, at the end of November 2007, expressing her confidence to CBS’s Katie Couric that the Democratic Party’s nomination for President was as good as hers. Hillary was the “inevitable” candidate for 2008. The race was going to be over very soon. Nobody stood a chance against her. And almost everyone agreed. The fact that history turned out differently tells you at least two different things. First, that the Obama campaign (for the […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Is the Labour Party campaigning hard enough for the European elections?

    Is the Labour Party campaigning hard enough for the European elections?

    In a week that supposedly signalled an end of the Cost of Living Crisis as wages begin to rise faster than inflation, Ed Miliband and Ed Balls will feel vindicated to learn that as far as LabourList readers are concerned, at least, it’s not over yet. An overwhelming 94% of those who responded to our survey this week believe the Cost of Living Crisis continues. That will certainly give new strategist David Axelrod something to work with, if activists are convinced […]

    Read more →
  • News Anyone for an Easter (Cl)Egg?

    Anyone for an Easter (Cl)Egg?

    The Mirror today have a story about a Labour attack on Nick Clegg – a chocolate “Easter Clegg”. It’s ‘completely hollow, melts under pressure and leaves bad taste in mouth”. The box also contains a “free mug”. Here’s a photo: Seemingly the Easter Clegg is “100% Authentically Conservative” and should be stored in David Cameron’s pocket. Meanwhile, both The Sun and The Telegraph claim this morning that Miliband would be happy to appoint Nick Clegg as Deputy PM in the event […]

    Read more →
  • News Ed Miliband’s Easter Message

    Ed Miliband’s Easter Message

    Here’s Ed Miliband’s Easter Message – touching on his recent trip to the Holy Land, and the work Christians do in their communities across Britain: “As Christians across Great Britain and the rest of the world gather to celebrate the most important event in the Christian faith, I would like to wish you all a happy Easter. “It was a privilege for me to visit the Holy Land in the lead up to Easter this year. I will be thinking […]

    Read more →