Osborne’s chaos on housing harms the vulnerable

3rd March, 2016 3:00 pm


This week the Government sneaked out a statement admitting that George Osborne’s crude cuts to housing benefit for people in supported homes will be delayed while Ministers frantically do what they should have done months ago and examine the impact of the Chancellor’s plans.

It’s a small but important victory for Labour and the charities, housing associations and councils that have been campaigning to stop these cuts. It’s a pre-Budget backtrack by the Chancellor but only a small step back, which is totally insufficient.    

We first exposed this as a national concern in December and challenged Ministers again with an opposition debate in Parliament in January. Jeremy Corbyn raised it at Prime Minister’s Questions last month.

We’ve been saying from the start these crude cuts will be a catastrophe for those who can least afford them.

The National Housing Federation predicts that 156,000 homes could close – almost half of all of this type of specialist accommodation.

This would leave thousands of frail elderly people, those with disabilities, veterans, people who are homeless and women fleeing domestic violence without anywhere to turn. Already the impact of the planned cut is being felt, with plans for 2,400 new specialist supported homes having been scrapped because of these changes.

This crude short-term cut is a false economy. Providers of supported housing take pressure off public services like the NHS and the police. If homes are closed, it is the public sector that will have to step in to help those who rely on them.

Just like with tax credits, these cuts are a mark of the Chancellor’s misjudgement. He has over-reached himself: first, by making crude cuts to meet extreme fiscal targets with no care for the consequences and second, by believing such benefit cuts will prove “good” politics when they are bad policy and bad politics. 

This cavalier “cut first, think later” approach has caused policy panic. In response to my questioning, Ministers now admit they don’t even know how many people will be affected, what the average loss in housing benefit support will be or how many specialist homes will have to be closed as a result. 

Ministers are now rushing to finish an evaluation exercise to answer these most basic questions.

Campaigners must now use the two weeks until the Budget to make the case to their MPs and to Ministers that the Chancellor must now go further and not just delay but scrap these crude cuts. 

For the Chancellor’s part, he must use the Budget to make clear he will halt these extreme plans, publish a full impact assessment and consult fully with providers to safeguard the future for this essential housing. 

If he doesn’t, then his political choice to close vital homes at the heart of the lives of thousands of elderly and very vulnerable tenants will be clear – and Labour will make sure this haunts him and his Party all the way to the 2020 Election.


John Healey is Shadow Secretary of State for Housing and Planning

To report anything from the comment section, please e-mail [email protected]


  • Comment Featured For the good of the party and the country, Labour cannot go on like this

    For the good of the party and the country, Labour cannot go on like this

      We cannot go on like this. It has been a devastating couple of days for the Labour Party in which it has lost a respected shadow Foreign Secretary, more than half the shadow Cabinet and some 34 shadow ministers in total. That was all before last night’s meeting of the PLP descended into a “brutal” row. This has all happened at a time of almost unprecedented political and economic turmoil over Brexit with the pound falling to its lowest level […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Uncategorized Heated PLP meeting spills out into Commons corridors

    Heated PLP meeting spills out into Commons corridors

    “Brutal” was the word used by several MPs as they left tonight’s meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party. Even by the bad-tempered tone of the Monday night meetings since Jeremy Corbyn’s election as leader, the latest session was something else. With discussion of the motion of “no confidence” in Corbyn scheduled for discussion, the room was packed to the rafters; even the leader’s staff struggled to get in the room. It meant both the discussion and the venue were heated: “It was like […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Corbyn addresses crowd of up to 10,000 on eve of confidence vote

    Corbyn addresses crowd of up to 10,000 on eve of confidence vote

    Jeremy Corbyn tonight called on thousands of demonstrators to “stay united for the world we want to live in” at Momentum’s #KeepCorbyn rally. The Labour leader appeared before an angry but crowd of supporters who had gathered at a snap demonstration. The rally was organised by Momentum and was designed to mobilise Corbyn’s wide support from the membership after more than 30 shadow frontbenchers resigned in 48 hours. In an impassioned speech to his supporters, Corbyn outlined his vision for Labour, saying […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News LIVEBLOG: MPs’ meeting and Corbyn rally at end of a day of drama

    LIVEBLOG: MPs’ meeting and Corbyn rally at end of a day of drama

    More than half of the shadow Cabinet members has resigned after Hilary Benn was sacked on Saturday night. Most of those positions were filled early Monday morning – although resignations from junior shadow ministerial roles are also coming through. We’ll be bringing you all the Labour frontbench news as it comes through. 22.46 Tonight’s meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) has been described as “brutal” by people who attended. MPs debated the motion of no confidence in Corbyn. Conor Pope has the details. 21.50 […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Seats and Selections Exclusive: 57 PPCs call on Corbyn to quit

    Exclusive: 57 PPCs call on Corbyn to quit

    Nearly 60 Labour parliamentary candidates have called for Jeremy Corbyn to resign as leader and said the party would “fail” in a general election. The former PPCs, who stood seats across London and the south-east, the Midlands, Scotland and Wales, said Labour needs a leader who would be seen as a “credible Prime Minister” with a vision for the whole of Britain. The letter has been signed by 57 candidates and sent to John Cryer, chair of the parliamentary Labour Party […]

    Read more →

LabourList Daily Email

Everything Labour. Every weekday morning

Share with your friends