The Jewish Labour Movement held its annual general meeting on Sunday, when it elected Mike Katz as national movement chair and Ruth Smeeth – replacing Luciana Berger, who has quit Labour to form a new party – as parliamentary chair.
Katz fought off incumbent Ivor Caplin, as well as Colin Appleby, who ran on a platform advocating disaffiliation from the Labour Party – an idea that was rejected as JLM activists pledged to “stay and fight” rather than sever the 99-year link.
The former Camden councillor and parliamentary candidate, who pledged to raise funds for a professional organiser and build relationships with youth networks, reportedly won by a significant margin.
In his candidate statement, Katz said: “We have a party leadership which continues to insult, ignore and disrespect us and the many progressive Jews we represent.”
JLM members did not opt to disaffiliate from Labour at the AGM, but did pass a motion of no confidence in Jeremy Corbyn almost unanimously following speeches from Labour MPs Margaret Hodge, Ruth Smeeth and Louise Ellman.
The motion said that the party leadership – including its NEC, the shadow cabinet and the general secretary – had “fundamentally failed to address antisemitism” and “continue to provoke” JLM by, for example, ending the use of the body for antisemitism training.
The JLM motion resolved: “To make a proclamation stating that we have no confidence in Jeremy Corbyn and our belief that he is unfit to be Prime Minister.”
The closest vote of the day, with 81 votes in favour and 67 against, was on an amendment to the ‘Labour Party antisemitism’ policy motion. The proposed change removed condemnation of Corbynite group Momentum and replaced it with criticism of Jewish Voice for Labour.
Where the motion cited “Momentum, CLPD and LRC” – the latter referring to the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy and the Labour Representation Committee – the named groups became “CLPD, the LRC and JVL”. They were said to have “acted… to protect and support those engaging in antisemitism”.
A passage approving of Momentum’s recent actions was added. JLM noted: “That Momentum has, for the last year, committed itself to tackling antisemitism within the Labour Party and wider society, through educational videos directed at Labour Party members, calling out and reporting antisemitic posts online, and joining JLM and other groups in protest against the likes of David Icke & Gilad Atzmon.”
Activists also passed a motion in favour of a “People’s Vote”, urging Labour to campaign for another referendum on Brexit.
National executive committee – full results:
National movement chair:
Mike KATZ – elected
Peter MASON – elected
National vice chair(s)+:
Joe GOLDBERG – elected
Sarah SACKMAN – elected
Stephane SAVARY – elected
Cathy ASHLEY – elected
Adam LANGLEBEN – elected
Izzy LENGA – elected
Local government officer:
Joshua GARFIELD – elected
Alex RICHARDSON – elected
Ella ROSE – elected
Liron VELLEMAN – elected
Political education officer:
Rebecca FILER – elected
Trade union officer:
Miriam MIRWITCH – elected
Youth & students officer:
Luisa ATTFIELD & Jack LUBNER – elected
Parliamentary & political council:
National parliamentary chair: Ruth Smeeth MP
National president: Dame Louise Ellman MP
National vice president (Commons): Dame Margaret Hodge MP
National vice president (Lords): Baroness Meta Ramsay
On the same day of the AGM, The Sunday Times reported that leaked emails showed the party had failed to discipline members accused of antisemitism and that Corbyn’s office had intervened in numerous cases.
A Labour spokesperson said: “This is another seriously misleading Sunday Times story, full of wrong figures, inaccurate claims and complete falsehoods. The selective use of leaked of emails has excluded information in the same email chains showing the opposite of what is alleged in the article.”
Ruth Smeeth told Channel 4 News that she had Whatsapped Corbyn on Saturday evening to ask about the reports, and he received the message but did not reply.
“My mother had to read that this morning. This is not what any of us should be experiencing.”
Labour MP Ruth Smeeth says her own party’s response to antisemitism allegations is “simply not good enough”. pic.twitter.com/G27piLXwjz
— Channel 4 News (@Channel4News) April 7, 2019
On Sunday morning, Baroness Chakrabarti appeared on Sky’s Ridge on Sunday. Commenting on the latest antisemitism story and the JLM meeting, the Labour peer and frontbencher said:
“My plea to the Jewish Labour Movement is to stay in the labour movement and to tackle racism together, not to personalise it and make it about Jeremy Corbyn because he is one person and he won’t be leader forever.”
Shadow Attorney General Baroness Chakrabarti says her colleagues have challenged a number of allegations in @thesundaytimes, but acknowledges the Labour Party has had a problem with antisemitism #Ridge.
— Ridge on Sunday (@RidgeOnSunday) April 7, 2019