Tories plan binding cross departmental cuts meeting – but we have to move on from our current line

June 25, 2009 9:18 am

Scissors Cut SutsBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

The Tories are already planning meetings to bind governmental departments to wholesale public service cuts, a year before an election is due. George Osborne, were he to make it to Number 11, would hold a meeting within days of taking power to bind any and all new Conservative government ministers to deep reductions in investment in schools, hospital and policing, according to shadow cabinet sources cited in the Guardian.

The paper also suggests that new Tory officials would be asked to make the cuts as early as possible, before they can grow too attached to their departmenal interests. That suggests a blind, uninformed set of arbitrary cuts, the sort of scything in the dark at projects that affect people’s lives we should fear from a Cameron government.

Indeed, the Guardian also says that under the new Tory plans, the Treasury will be guided by the markets, not public need.

Of course, spending reductions are going to be required over the next few years. Yesterday Meryvn King urged the government to sharply reduce public borrowing. So I’m still concerned that the Party line “Labour investment over Tory cuts” is a dead end. It’s a ten year old argument not valid for this recession.

We should be fighting the next election on who is best placed to make those cuts to ensure the smoothest possible growth out of the recession; arguing a case for where smaller investment cuts can be mitigated best and why continued investment in the most critical frontline services – such as social and affordable housing – is important.

Instead of “Tory cuts” and “Mr 10%”, Labour needs to say “yes, unfortunately we’re going to have to reduce funding for some services; but we have a record of investing in the most important frontline services, and your school, your Sure Start centre, your hospital and your local comunity centre are all completely safe.”

UPDATE: Here’s the latest HQ video on those cuts:

Related posts:

  1. The dividing line between Labour and the Tories at local level has become clearer
  2. Death by a hundred cuts – stop the Tories slashing local services
  3. LunchtimeList No.61 – This is not the current edition. To receive our most recent daily digest of the news and blogs, enter your email at the top right of the site now!
  4. Now for cross party Commons reform
  5. Boris has left a £4m financial hole in King’s Cross

Comments are closed

Latest

  • Comment The Labour Party was near the edge – are we back from the brink?

    The Labour Party was near the edge – are we back from the brink?

    Let’s be honest, every now and again you’ve taken a peek over the edge….the edge of the Labour party’s collapse.  And as the cliff edge has got steadily got closer, peeking has become like that itch you just can’t leave alone. If you can summon up the nerve to teeter on the edge and stare down the cliff face,  the scars of the Blair-Brown era emerge: declining membership; an exiting of talent; an experience for those who’ve stayed that remains [...]

    Read more →
  • News Ed (re)defines the squeezed middle

    Ed (re)defines the squeezed middle

    In a wide-ranging speech last night in Sheffield, Ed Miliband sought to explain what he means by the squeezed middle – and what he should have said when he was questioned about it months ago: “When John Humphrys asked me what I meant by the squeezed middle, I should have said this: The squeezed middle are working people. People bound together, now as in the past, by a set of values. The value of working hard. Whether it is in [...]

    Read more →
  • Local Government News Prezza for Police Commissioner?

    Prezza for Police Commissioner?

    According to the Hull and East Riding Mail: “Lord Prescott said: “I want the opportunity to continue my public service to the region with a mandate from the people to protect the community and target criminals. “I feel that after proudly serving as a local MP for 40 years and as a cabinet minister for 10 years, I have the experience to listen to the public and help be their strong voice in supporting the police and holding them to [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured A big moment for the NHS – and for blogging

    A big moment for the NHS – and for blogging

    Today marks a big moment – not just in British blogging history, but in British political history. The decision by cabinet ministers to go to ConHome calling for the health bill to be dropped is a breach of collective responsibility, that much is clear. That they have briefed ConHome anonymously makes very little difference – Tim Montgomerie is a scrupulous character who can be taken at his word. These cabinet ministers, whoever they are, are angry. And they want this [...]

    Read more →
  • Comment Is there a thin blue line for the new Police and Crime Commissioners?

    Is there a thin blue line for the new Police and Crime Commissioners?

    The process to select candidates for the new Police Crime Commissioners is underway. The Labour Party NEC will be long-listing at the end of February. The Liberal Democrats have, I understand, said that they do not intend to field candidates from a nationally organised position but will offer support to local parties taking the initiative. In the past, the Conservatives have declared that they will be hosting open primaries but no news is yet emerging on when and where these [...]

    Read more →