How bad are the polls for Ed?

December 17, 2010 6:01 pm

ed miliband leadershipBy Mark Ferguson / @markfergsuonuk

The media narrative is set. Ed Miliband has had a “faltering” start to his time as leader, it hasn’t been a good start, and he needs to improve. Over at Open Democracy Stewart Weir has successfully demolished this argument. Miliband has Labour ahead in several opinion polls only months after a crushing electoral defeat. The Lib Dems are in trouble and wallowing in single figures and now (with his new communications team in place) Ed can focus his full fire on the Tories.

Ah, but Ed’s personal polling is poor though, I hear you say. The recent Ipsos-Mori poll was trailed as being something of a personal disaster for Ed, with a satisfaction rating of just +1. However, the percentage of people who are satisfied with Miliband is much higher than similar figures for David Cameron, William Hague, Michael Howard and IDS, as Mike Smithson points out at Political Betting:

“The comparative MORI polls from previous opposition leaders puts him in much better light. Hague was 22-28 satisfied-dissatisfied after three months; IDS 24-22; Howard 30-22; Cameron 32-19 while Miliband was at 35-34.”

“Also the Labour leader’s performance is even better when you take into account the firm’s big methodology change in June 2008 when it stopped doing face-to-face interviews for political surveys.”

“Carrying out fieldwork in the old way tended to produce much more Labour-friendly figures and Tory unfriendly ones. Before the change Cameron never had a satisfaction level of more than 40%. After the change he never went below that number.”

Despite being a relative unknown to much of the population, a higher percentage of the public have a positive impression of Ed Miliband than any of the last four Tory leaders at a similar time in their leaderships. This is despite being forced to face both the CSR and the SDSR (as well as taking two weeks’ paternity leave) inside his first three months in the job.

There’s certainly room for improvement in these numbers – but rumours of Miliband’s polling demise are somewhat premature, and overstated.

Comments are closed

Latest

  • Comment Schools that show what’s possible

    Schools that show what’s possible

    This week the school where I was a deputy head teacher got it’s first ever exam results with 82% of its students achieving 5 GCSEs A*-C including English and maths. 91% got C or above in English and 89% in maths. Almost 1 in 3 achieved 5A/A*s. The City Academy, Hackney is on the site of Homerton House which closed in 2006 with just 17% of its students leaving school with 5 GCESs. The school serves two of the most […]

    Read more →
  • News Hague claimed expenses for protest meeting on NHS reforms (but he backed them every single time)

    Hague claimed expenses for protest meeting on NHS reforms (but he backed them every single time)

    The Mirror reports today that: “William Hague claimed hundreds of pounds on expenses to fund a protest meeting – to fight his own Government’s NHS reforms. The Cabinet minister was accused of hypocrisy for campaigning against hated health service cuts in his constituency, while backing the ­Coalition’s changes in Westminster.” Hague spent over £300 on the meeting, including hiring a venue and advertising the meeting in his local paper. The Mirror reports that he voiced “acute concern” and said “I will take all the views […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Angela Eagle calls on Tories to “come clean” over membership figures

    Angela Eagle calls on Tories to “come clean” over membership figures

    There have been reports in recent weeks that Tory Chairman Michael Green  Grant Shapps is set to announce new Tory membership figures at their conference. However, these “higher membership numbers” may not be as they seem, as over Cameron’s time as Tory leader 118,600 members have abandoned his party. With that in mind, Angela Eagle has written to Shapps urging him to come clean, rather than fudging the numbers. Here’s the letter: Dear Grant, I am writing to urge you to […]

    Read more →
  • Comment 10 things the Government can do to help the high street

    10 things the Government can do to help the high street

    As new high streets minister Penny Mordaunt plans to embark on a national town centre tour, Labour’s high street advisor Bill Grimsey offers 10 suggestions on where she should take immediate action to stop the rot, rebuild confidence and help lead a genuine high street recovery. 1. Recognise that town centres and high streets can no longer thrive as a retail destination alone. It’s well documented that there’s too much retail floor space in the UK. I can’t fault Penny’s enthusiasm […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Scotland Scotland: we need a federal future

    Scotland: we need a federal future

    Gordon Brown is right, the work on a more sustainable settlement for the UK must begin the day after a prospective No vote – the status quo is morally and politically indefensible. As has been much noted, an overwhelming number of Scots are in favour of more powers for the Scottish Parliament. If the desire for autonomy under a common unionist structure is not accommodated, it will only push more Scots into the nationalist camp. We must not simply win […]

    Read more →