How bad are the polls for Ed?

December 17, 2010 6:01 pm

ed miliband leadershipBy Mark Ferguson / @markfergsuonuk

The media narrative is set. Ed Miliband has had a “faltering” start to his time as leader, it hasn’t been a good start, and he needs to improve. Over at Open Democracy Stewart Weir has successfully demolished this argument. Miliband has Labour ahead in several opinion polls only months after a crushing electoral defeat. The Lib Dems are in trouble and wallowing in single figures and now (with his new communications team in place) Ed can focus his full fire on the Tories.

Ah, but Ed’s personal polling is poor though, I hear you say. The recent Ipsos-Mori poll was trailed as being something of a personal disaster for Ed, with a satisfaction rating of just +1. However, the percentage of people who are satisfied with Miliband is much higher than similar figures for David Cameron, William Hague, Michael Howard and IDS, as Mike Smithson points out at Political Betting:

“The comparative MORI polls from previous opposition leaders puts him in much better light. Hague was 22-28 satisfied-dissatisfied after three months; IDS 24-22; Howard 30-22; Cameron 32-19 while Miliband was at 35-34.”

“Also the Labour leader’s performance is even better when you take into account the firm’s big methodology change in June 2008 when it stopped doing face-to-face interviews for political surveys.”

“Carrying out fieldwork in the old way tended to produce much more Labour-friendly figures and Tory unfriendly ones. Before the change Cameron never had a satisfaction level of more than 40%. After the change he never went below that number.”

Despite being a relative unknown to much of the population, a higher percentage of the public have a positive impression of Ed Miliband than any of the last four Tory leaders at a similar time in their leaderships. This is despite being forced to face both the CSR and the SDSR (as well as taking two weeks’ paternity leave) inside his first three months in the job.

There’s certainly room for improvement in these numbers – but rumours of Miliband’s polling demise are somewhat premature, and overstated.

Comments are closed

Latest

  • News Photo: Miliband arrives at the White House

    Photo: Miliband arrives at the White House

    Ed Miliband is meeting the US National Security Adviser Susan Rice (and…maybe someone else) this evening. Here’s Miliband arriving at the White House (photo courtesy of @edstradling): And here’s Miliband and Douglas Alexander approaching the White House: There may well be another photo this evening – if there is, we’ll post it here…

    Read more →
  • News Tory MP criticises Cameron, saying it’s “tokenism” that got women into the cabinet

    Tory MP criticises Cameron, saying it’s “tokenism” that got women into the cabinet

    Richard Drax, Conservative MP for South Dorset, has said that David Cameron’s decision to promote more women MPs (but remember, with some demotions, on our count there are only 2 more women in the Cabinet than prior to the reshuffle) to the Cabinet is tokenism. On his website, Drax said that he didn’t oppose women “getting the top jobs” but said they “like their male counterparts” must “get their on merit and not just because they are women and a […]

    Read more →
  • News Polling Labour move to 8 point lead in Lord Ashcroft poll

    Labour move to 8 point lead in Lord Ashcroft poll

    Often a Cabinet reshuffle will see a polling boost for the party in question – but not for David Cameron. Over the course of the last week, the Tories have dropped five points, according to the latest Lord Ashcroft poll, with Labour taking an eight point lead. The results are: Labour 35%, Tories 27%, UKIP 17%, Lib Dems 7%, Greens 7% Since beginning his weekly polls in May, Ashcroft’s results have been notoriously volatile, often appearing to be the most extreme […]

    Read more →
  • News Blair backs Miliband agenda in leadership anniversary lecture

    Blair backs Miliband agenda in leadership anniversary lecture

    Tony Blair today gave what could be viewed as his biggest endorsement yet of Ed Miliband’s leadership of the Labour Party. In a lecture to mark the twentieth anniversary of his election as Labour leader, the former Prime Minister spelled out his ideas on matters such as devolution, Europe and “the centre ground” – and all seemed to echo what Miliband has planned for Government. Speaking at the Philip Gould Memorial Lecture, organised by Progress, Blair suggested that Miliband was […]

    Read more →
  • News Lib Dem minister says his party would go into coalition with Labour

    Lib Dem minister says his party would go into coalition with Labour

    Ed Davey, Liberal Democrat MP and current Energy Secretary in the coalition government, has said that he thinks Labour will be the biggest party in 2015 and, if this is the case, he hopes the Lib Dems will go into coalition with them. It’s reported that Davey, speaking at a conference in East London, had said that if Labour failed to win a majority but were the biggest party in 2015, the Lib Dems would use their experience with the Tories to […]

    Read more →