Healey to Cameron: Stop misrepresenting your NHS changes – and me

May 12, 2011 1:15 pm

Author:

Share this Article

John HealeyRt Hon David Cameron MP
Prime Minister
10 Downing Street
London
SW1A 2AA

11 May 2011

You again misrepresented my position on your Government’s NHS reorganisation today at PMQs, this time in response to Ed Miliband.

It confirms your desperation to claim some support for your NHS reorganisation when you try to pray me in aid as Labour shadow health secretary, when I have been leading arguments against your NHS plans since the early autumn.

This is characteristic of the way you have conducted debate on the NHS. You have simply not been straight. You did not tell people before the Election about your plans for the biggest reorganisation in NHS history. In fact you personally promised the opposite both before the Election and importantly afterwards in your Coalition Agreement, which pledged to “stop the top-down reorganisations of the NHS that have got in the way of patient care”.

Now you continue in a similar way. You and your Ministers fail to tell people the full story about the fundamental changes to the NHS in your health bill. You misrepresent the changes you are forcing on the NHS, just as you misrepresent me.

Below is the Hansard record of my comments from the Opposition Day Debate earlier this week, from which you picked the very first part:

9 May 2011 : Column 913

John Healey: There is nothing wrong with the general aims of the changes, but what the Government are doing is different from what they are saying. In one third of the legislation, they are not setting up GP consortia or reducing bureaucracy in the NHS, but setting up the NHS as a full-blown market. That is the wrong prescription for our NHS, and it is patients who will suffer.

Nobody could see this as a statement of support for your NHS reorganisation.

Once again you are doing what you and the Health Secretary have been doing for some time – misrepresenting those critical of your plans as supporters, not being straight with people and downplaying or denying the far-reaching changes you are making to our health service.

The NHS deserves better.

I look forward to your response.

John Healey MP
Shadow Health Secretary

Comments are closed

Latest

  • Featured McFadden rejoins Labour front bench as Europe Minister in (mini) Labour reshuffle

    McFadden rejoins Labour front bench as Europe Minister in (mini) Labour reshuffle

    Update: Pat McFadden becomes Shadow Europe Minister, replacing Gareth Thomas. Thomas moves within the Shadow FCO team to become Shadow Minister for North Africa and the Middle East. Ian Lucas moves from Foreign Affairs to Defence – he’ll be covering international security strategy. And last but not least, Yvonne Fovargue moves from Defence to Education replacing Rushanara Ali as Shadow Minister for Young People. That means McFadden is the one new recruit for Miliband’s front bench, speaking this evening, he said: “I’m […]

    Read more →
  • Comment The Tories lie about the NHS in Wales to distract us from what they’re doing in England

    The Tories lie about the NHS in Wales to distract us from what they’re doing in England

    Today we have seen the Tory lie machine out once again attacking Wales and distorting the truth about the NHS in Wales. It doesn’t take a genius to work out why: they are trying to distract attention from the harm the Tory-led Government is doing to the NHS in England. Yes, like in all health systems, there are pressures on the NHS in Wales. But the reality is that the NHS in Wales has improved dramatically over the last decade […]

    Read more →
  • News Weekly Survey: the National Minimum Wage, Ukip and the Greens, and the Mansion Tax

    Weekly Survey: the National Minimum Wage, Ukip and the Greens, and the Mansion Tax

    This week, Alan Milburn, who chairs to commission on social mobility and child poverty said that Labour’s plans to raise the National Minimum Wage  (NMW) to £8 by 2020  were “not at all ambitious”. In response, the Labour Party said this criticism was “plainly absurd” and argued that under their proposals the NWM would be “rising more than twice as fast as under the Tory-led government”. What do you think? Do you think the Labour Party need to be pledging […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Parliament has more important priorities than this spiffwaddle

    Parliament has more important priorities than this spiffwaddle

    Today Parliament will debate the Government’s Social Action, Responsibility and Heroism Bill, or SARAH for short. But SARAH hasn’t had a great life. She came into the world with enormous fanfare. The Justice Secretary, Chris Grayling, made grand promises that she would slay the “health and safety” dragon, and deal with the “compensation culture”. He promised SARAH would promote volunteering and protect have a go heroes from the threat of litigation. And all delivered despite her diminutive size! She is […]

    Read more →
  • News Balls lays out further plans for a “fair” Mansion Tax

    Balls lays out further plans for a “fair” Mansion Tax

    Ed Balls has today further elaborated on Labour’s plans for a Mansion Tax – the funds of which would go towards increasing the NHS budget by £2.5 billion a year. Writing in the Evening Standard, Balls reiterated that this tax would apply to properties worth £2 million and more – consequently meaning that the tax would apply to 0.5% of homes. And he was sure to stress again that this tax won’t apply to people who have lived in high […]

    Read more →
7ads6x98y