The British disease: short-termism

August 23, 2011 9:26 am

Author:

Share this Article

Union JackBy Adam Lent, Associate Fellow at IPPR

The recent wild fluctuations in equity markets have once again highlighted the extent to which short term concerns can shape a defining sector of our economy. Unfortunately this is not an outlook confined to the trading floors. Current political debate is now overwhelmingly shaped by a short-termist attitude to economic growth.

The original Conservative claim that growth would automatically follow tough action on the public deficit may have been ditched but it has only been replaced by claims that various tweaks to taxation, employment law or planning regulations offer short-cut routes to a healthier economy. This is a particularly unhappy state of affairs because it is impossible to come to genuinely meaningful conclusions about what we should be doing to address immediate economic problems, unless we are clear about what we should do to address the longer term.

In particular, Osborne and Cable need to recognise that even if we see a return of healthier growth over coming months, this will not necessarily mean that the UK economy is out of the woods. New economic powers in Asia and elsewhere are striding into the global market with increasing confidence and business know-how. Simultaneously, business practices in a wide variety of sectors are being radically and speedily transformed by the new general purpose technology of the interactive web. Similar confluences in the Twentieth century, such as the rise of mass production and the US in the 1910/20s and flexible production in Japan in the 1960s/70s, saw the UK’s share of global markets shrink as the growth and productivity of domestic business increasingly lagged international competitors.

Worryingly the weaknesses that led to these historical failures still exist today. A new analysis of international economic data, published this week by IPPR and written by myself and David Nash, reveals that the UK has not shaken off its long term underperformance in four vital areas: business investment, skills, business innovation, and presence of UK firms in emerging markets. These crucial elements of any economy ensure that the businesses which drive growth are able to adapt effectively to market and technological changes.

Concerns about these persistent weaknesses are not new. Anxious debates about one or more have emerged at different times throughout the Twentieth Century. Unfortunately those debates characteristically take off once the economic consequences of the weaknesses have become undeniable and usually irresolvable. For example, the failure of British business to modernise in the immediate post-war period only became an issue of serious political concern by the early 1960s when French and German companies were well ahead of British business in terms of productivity and market share.

This is why a debate about growth that fails to set short-term goals within the context of a wider policy framework designed to address the UK’s persistent economic weaknesses will never create the sort of longer term, sustainable growth that policy-makers claim they have been aiming for since the Crash of 2008.

So when we discuss the current problem with credit flows to British businesses, we also need to understand how other countries use the state more effectively to direct investment to innovative firms over the long term.

When we question how we get young people back into work, we also need to consider recasting our skills and training system so that it can respond more strategically and speedily to technological change.

When politicians laud success stories like the Old Street Roundabout, we need to appreciate that the web is not simply an issue for the IT sector but a huge threat to businesses that do not have a bold programme of policy support in place to aid innovation.

And when politicians of all parties talk of the need to turn Britain into a leading exporter, it has to be accepted that while expanding our export credit guarantee scheme is a crucial step, it will prove ineffective unless it is one small piece of a much larger policy jigsaw designed to address the problems of investment, skills and innovation.

Comments are closed

Latest

  • Comment Affordable housing not fox hunting

    Affordable housing not fox hunting

    Attending my first Labour Conference as a Parliamentary Candidate (PPC) was always going to be an interesting experience. And whilst Conference was rightly focusing on the strategy to win our all important key seats in seven months time, both the fringe events and policy announcements showed that there is now a clear policy platform to allow us to take our One Nation Labour Party to the doorsteps of even the most challenging seats. Having been selected for a ‘safe’ Tory […]

    Read more →
  • News TSSA union members vote to keep poitical fund

    TSSA union members vote to keep poitical fund

    Members of the Transport Salaried Staffs’ Association (TSSA) trade union have voted to keep their political fund, which goes towards campaigning for policies to help their members, as well as reaffirming their links to the Labour Party. Unions have been required to ballot members on whether they want to keep their political fund every ten years ever since the Tories brought through the legislation in the 1980s – and since then there have been no high profile cases of members voting […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Labour and the rise of the machines

    Labour and the rise of the machines

    Technology is already transforming our homes in ways we could not have dreamed of only a few years ago, and these same technologies are altering how we work and interact. The impact of the automation of jobs and mechanisation has created increasing uncertainty surrounding the employment prospects of white-collar workers previously immune to such problems. At conference, Ed Balls was right to say that “across the developed world, rapid technological change is replacing traditional skilled jobs too – in banking […]

    Read more →
  • News Labour supporters want an EU referendum, latest poll finds

    Labour supporters want an EU referendum, latest poll finds

    A recent poll has found that 45% of Labour supporters are for a referendum on the EU, with 36% against it. The polling conducted by YouGov for think tank British Future between 14th and 15th September also found that when looked at in terms of the electorate as a whole 57%  of people are in favour of a referendum and only 23% are against. YouGov said that when asked, 52% of those who took part in the polls largely believed […]

    Read more →
  • News Are the Tories more likely to protect hedge funds than the NHS?

    Are the Tories more likely to protect hedge funds than the NHS?

    Well, yes – according to the people of Birmingham. It’s been reported that in his speech tomorrow David Cameron will attempt to claw back some legitimacy for the Tories when it comes to the NHS. But, it looks like Cameron’s latest policy announcement (where he’ll promise that by 2020 everyone in England will be able to access a GP every day of the week) will do little to undo the public’s belief that the Tories can’t be trusted with the […]

    Read more →
7ads6x98y