Croydon, Middlesbrough, Rotherham – By-election Liveblog

November 29, 2012 10:02 pm

02.00: Ladies and gentlemen, after four hours, that’s a wrap. Three solid wins for Labour tonight, three swings to Labour. The only fly in the ointment is the low turnout, and the worrying rise of protest parties – but I’ll return to that later this morning.

Goodnight everyone – and congratulations to Andy McDonald, Sarah Champion and Steve Reed. Thanks for sticking with us. See you again at the next by-election (which hopefully won’t be too soon…)

01.46: Result in Croydon is as follows:

Steve Reed (Lab) 15,898 (64.71%, +8.69%)
Andy Stranack (C) 4,137 (16.84%, -7.28%)
Winston McKenzie (Ukip) 1,400 (5.70%, +3.97%)
Marisha Ray (LD) 860 (3.50%, -10.48%)
Shasha Islam Khan (Green) 855 (3.48%, +1.51%)
Lee Jasper (Respect) 707 (2.88%, +2.35%)
Stephen Hammond (CPA) 192 (0.78%)
Richard Edmonds (NF) 161 (0.66%)
Ben Stevenson (Comm) 119 (0.48%, +0.17%)
John Cartwright (Loony) 110 (0.45%)
Simon Lane (Nine eleven) 66 (0.27%)
Robin Smith (Young) 63 (0.26%)

Congratulations to Steve Reed, the new MP for Croydon North, and Labour’s third new MP of the night. That’s a hat-trick.

01.41: Labour got 64% of the vote in Croydon North. Bloody hell.

01.37: If we get the 10,000+ majority we’re expecting in Croydon North, then it means there has been a swing to Labour in all three seats.

01.31: So the Lib Dems came 8th in Rotherham, behind the English Democrats. However, it gets worse for them. The English Democrat candidate in Rotherham used to be a Lib Dem.

01.30: Here’s that Middlesbrough result –

  • Andy McDonald (Lab) 10,201 (60.48%, +14.60%)
  • Richard Elvin (UKIP) 1,990 (11.80%, +8.10%)
  • George Selmer (Lib Dems) 1,672 (9.91%, -10.00%)
  • Ben Houchen (Cons) 1,063 (6.30%, -12.48%)
  • Imdad Hussain (Peace) 1,060 (6.28%)
  • Peter Foreman (BNP) 328 (1.94%, -3.90%)
  • John Malcolm (TUSC) 277 (1.64%)
  • Mark Heslehurst (ND) 275 (1.63%)

01.26: I’m now getting Lib Dems gloating at me because they saved one deposit tonight. Well done Lib Dems. I’m sure you’re all very proud…

01.23: In Middlesbrough, as in Rotherham, the Labour vote share has increased since 2010. UKIP second as expected, with the Lib Dems a remarkable third. Not bad for a minor party…

01.20: And as expected it’s a win for Labour in Middlesbrough – congratulations to Andy McDonald, our second Labour winner of the night.

01.08: Apologies – the Lib Dems came EIGHTH in Rotherham.

01.06: The collapse of the coalition parties is significant, but I’m starting to wonder if there’s more to this than meets the eyes. If, as we expect, UKIP also come second in Middlesbrough – does that mean UKIP could be the second (albeit a distant second) party in the North?

01.03: Looks like, for all of the bluster, Respect will follow up their 4th place in Rotherham with a 5th place (at best) in Croydon.

01.o0: The Lib Dems came SEVENTH in Rotherham, behind the English Democrats. The Tories were fifth. Ouch.

  • Sarah Champion (Lab) 9,866 (46.25%, +1.62%)
  • Jane Collins (UKIP) 4,648 (21.79%, +15.87%)
  • Marlene Guest (BNP) 1,804 (8.46%, -1.96%)
  • Yvonne Ridley (Respect) 1,778 (8.34%)
  • Simon Wilson (Cons) 1,157 (5.42%, -11.32%)
  • David Wildgoose (Eng Dem) 703 (3.30%)
  • Simon Copley (Ind) 582 (2.73%, -3.58%)
  • Michael Beckett (Lib Dems) 451 (2.11%, -13.87%)
  • Ralph Dyson (TUSC) 261 (1.22%)
  • Paul Dickson (Ind) 51 (0.24%)
  • Clint Bristow (ND) 29 (0.14%)

00.54: With a majority of over 5,000 – congratulations Sarah Champion, Labour’s new MP for Rotherham.

00.52: Labour’s majority down in Rotherham, but the vote share is up – from 44% to 46%.

00.50: Lib Dems got just 400 votes in Rotherham, I’m told…

00.46: In Rotherham, the result is imminent. Looks like a 4,000 Labour majority (which is good considering the circumstances) with UKIP 2nd, BNP 3rd, Respect 4th, and Tories 5th, according to Helen Pidd.

00.39: Certainly looking like Labour have well over 50% of the vote in Croydon North. That could be a majority of over 10,000. Blimey.

00.24: In fact, we hear that Lee Jasper and Respect will be losing their deposit too in Croydon North, in what is starting to look like a big win for Labour.

00.19: In Croydon North, the Greens are convinced that they’ve beaten Respect. Poor Lee Jasper, was all of that effort for 4th place?

00.12: We’ve had an update from a Labour source who says:

“We predict Middlesbrough and Croydon will be good Labour wins with 26% turnout. Rotherham is looking solid (34% turnout), with UKIP in second place. This is a very good set of results. The Lib Dems have performed disastrously in all three by-elections and could lose their deposits in all three. The Tories have seen a severe collapse to UKIP in Rotherham.”

00.08: Sarah Champion will be at the Rotherham count within half an hour, I’m told.

00.02: The Tories have conceded in Croydon North. Hardly a shock…

23.43: Some predictions to liven things up:

  • As I said earlier, I expect the Lib Dems to lose their deposit in all three by-elections
  • UKIP will come second in Rotherham AND Middlesbrough
  • And the Tories may lose their deposit in Middlesbrough – as well as struggling to hit double figures in Rotherham

23.39: Just been chasing details on Middlesbrough. Labour’s Andy McDonald about to arrive at the count, result within an hour. It’s business time…

23.30: Seemingly the turnout in Middlesbrough and Croydon will be in the low twenties for both. Emphasis on low (maybe as low as 21%).

23.18: You know how we said that the Lib Dems could lose a few deposits today? Keep your eye on the Tory totals too – it wouldn’t be a surprise to see them lose a deposit somewhere as well…

23.12: Although UKIP won’t win a seat tonight (we don’t think) I’d expect them to finish second in at least Rotherham, and perhaps elsewhere too. Which may give Cameron a headache tomorrow. That said, no party is going to look at such a low turnout and think “job done” I would hope…

23.07: Stop the front page! We have our first number of the night. Turnout in Rotherham is a low (but not earth shatteringly so) 33.89%. We may be getting towards the business end of the evening…

23.04: Right, so we’re just over an hour into the liveblog, and it looks almost certain that Labour will win Middlesbrough and Croydon North, and now Rotherham looks like it’s heading to Labour too. (Drums fingers on table…) I’m not complaining, but I was expecting tonight to be more dramatic than this.

Bring on the results…

23.00: According to the excellent Helen Pidd (who is becoming something of a by-election superstar for the Guardian), Nigel Farage is throwing in the towel for UKIP in Rotherham. She’s just tweeted:

Just seen Nigel Farage at the Rotherham byelection count. Says: “labour will win – but not by much. UKIP a massive second. Tories nowhere”

22.51: Nigel Farage is tweeting that UKIP are in second place on postal votes. I won’t get into electoral law here, but let’s just say Farage probably shouldn’t have tweeted that. However, since Labour ran a postal vote campaign, I’d imagine if Labour are ahead on postal votes that makes it far harder for UKIP to take the seat. And near impossible for Respect (who must be 3rd place or worse on postal votes).

22.46: An interesting suggestion arrives in my inbox – could the Lib Dems lose their deposit in all three by-elections today? In Corby they asked for twor ecounts to save their deposits. If they try that in all three tonight we could be up late…

22.39: Seemingly some people are  watching Question Time? I will have to be more entertaining to cut into their market share. Local BBC journo James Vincent has been saying that Labour people in Rotherham seem confident. That has eased my jitters, I remember from previous by-elections how reliable Vincent is. Incidentally he thinks the Rotherham count could be done by 2am.

I’ve checked this with some people in the know, and we may be in for an earlier night than expected – a high proportion of the votes in all three by-elections are postal votes, therefore they have already been verified and are ready to count.

22.32: Some top knowledge from Martin Tiedemann on Twitter who notes that:

“turnout will be affected by the addition of 15k electors in Croydon N on new register. Total electorate will be huge!”

22.25: With any by-election liveblog there’s one bit of information that everyone wants – the time the results are called so they can go to bed. I’m no different, so here’s when I understand we should expect the results:

Croydon: 1.30am
Middlesbrough: 2am
Rotherham: After 3am

 Get the coffee on…

22.16: Labour HQ evidently enjoy my by-election liveblogs as much as all of you do – a Labour source tells us:

“We’re quietly confident on Middlesbrough and Croydon with turnout in the mid-twenties. Rotherham turnout is mid-thirties – the Labour vote is holding up but we don’t know where the other votes are going.”

That largely backs up what we’ve been hearing from elsewhere, but it’s a decent indication of the party’s thinking. As for Rotherham in particular, whether that’s expectation management or not, I just became a little more concerned….

22.15: That said, I don’t want people to think I’m predicting a loss in Rotherham. As things stand I think we’ll squeak a win. But squeak might be the apt word.

22.12: And now for Rotherham. Friends, there’s a reason I left this one until last. Although turnout is still low in this one, it’s looking higher than either of the other two seats. With all of the controversy around the local council, the outgoing MP and the party selection, it’s also the one I’m most worried about. That said, I understand the Labour vote is holding up well – the question is who are those who aren’t voting Labour voting for? Rotherham is going to be close, I think. At least close enough to stay up for…

22.08: How’s it looking in Croydon North? Pretty good actually. Plenty of activists (as you’d expect for a London by-election) and although turnout will be low (perhaps slightly higher than Middlesbrough) there should be a sizeable Labour majority. That said, Steve Reed will struggle to have a majority of 16,481, when that might be closer to the total vote! Still, I’d be astonished if Steve Reed wasn’t also heading into the Commons enxt week as a newly minted MP.

22.04: Let’s go around the seats one by one and see where we are shall we? We’ll start with Middlesbrough where those on the ground seem confident that Andy McDonald will be elected as a Labour MP. No surprises there, though it’ll be interesting to see who comes second and what turnout is like…it comes be little over 20%.

22.00: The polls have closed in Middlesbrough, Croydon and Rotherham. You know what that means? It’s liveblogging time, of course. Three “safe” Labour seats. Three counts this evening, and, hopefully, three newly elected Labour MPs.

As a starter – familiarise yourselves with these numbers, which are the current Labour majorities in the three seats:

Croydon North – 16,481

Middlesbrough – 8,689

Rotherham – 10,462

  • Graeme Hancocks

    Oh sugar. I hope not Bradford West all over again….

  • s cullen

    much flatter presence on twitter than #corby ! cos not bellweather or marginal? Shame really!

  • ter33

    It depends what they mean by “holding up”. Often it means that it may be down somewhat, but not by a shocking amount. So if that’s the case, we are probably looking at a Labour share of 35-45% in Rotherham.

  • Braden Davy

    Looking forward to this blog! I’m following avidly on twitter, I honestly think Lib Dems will lose deposits in all 3 elections. Surge in UKIP could lead to a good showing, signs of Lib Dem collapse continuing!

  • John Ruddy

    I dont think he broke electoral law, because it was after polls closed….

  • Aaron Aababab

    All is not lost yet. The good guys may still win and Labour could be tossed aside (as it rightly should be)

  • kb32904

    Rotherham worries me because of the events over the last 2 weeks. As an aside, is anybody questioning why Farage kept the UKIP foster story to himself for over a week before it mysteriously got leaked to the Telegraph ? He confirmed it on C4 news last week.

  • Graeme Hancocks

    We don’t want dramatic….just three Labour wins.

  • LondonStatto

    Are we expecting Labour’s vote share to increase in any constituency?

  • Brumanuensis

    If UKIP are doing very well in second place, presumably that suggests they’ll do better than at Barnsley?

  • Graeme Hancocks

    Sky reporting Labour more and more confident of a reasonably good result in Rotherham. What a relief! All those additional prayers today….

  • volcanopete

    Labour gain, a surprise, win in Shipston on Stour (Stratford-upon-Avon) by-election from Conservatives Labour 613 Lib Dem 575 Con 331 Breakthrough in Stratford!

  • Northern Neanderthal

    Poor jasper! Loving how this night is going. Cheers for the updates mark

  • NT86

    At the next general election, you can be sure that much of the small Tory vote in safe northern Labour seats will transfer over to UIKIP. That’s on top of the likely vote increases in Tory heartlands. While I strongly agree with them on the need for controlled immigration policies, I disagree with some of their other areas like the seeming denial of climate change in their ranks.

    UKIP (and perhaps the Greens to a much lesser extent) are going to overtake the Lib Dems in coming years.

    Given the problems of the Labour selection process in Rotherham, it seems like they can breathe a massive sigh of relief if it’s being suggested that they’ll hold.

  • rekrab

    Hmmm, is it all about immigration and Europe! if UKIP beat the tories on every count will the likelyhood of an in/out European referendum be much closer?

    • jaime taurosangastre candelas

      I am not sure about the “likelihood”, but you can be sure that if the UKIP do beat the tories in each of these elections, the Mr Nigel Farage will be all over our televisions and newspapers proclaiming that the UKIP showing is evidence of a great national desire for a referendum, and I think he would probably be truthful. Actually, this will be uncomfortable for both the Prime Minister and the Mr Ed Miliband, both of whom rather hope the Euro-referendum question is not asked.

      I also hope it is not asked, but I am only an individual. I do not wish Britain to leave the EU (although many / most? people do), I rather want Britain to stay in the EU, but for the EU to transform itself into a pure trading alliance, no more.

      I am working on a Bob Seeger revelation for you for after Christmas when your boys have hopefully bought you some CDs. You will love it: all about poor men’s politics in the Great Depression.

      • rekrab

        UKIP,BNP and even the English Democratic getting over 500 votes, it all looks like the people of England have came across a big wall while out walking and on the big wall was a sign saying get out of Europe and nobody’s looking what is on the other side of the wall?

        • trotters1957

          The recent polls suggest that over 50% want us to leave the EU but it’s not as decisive as people think.
          When big business get behind a stay in campaign and all the main parties vote to stay in (even most Tories don’t want to actually leave the EU) that percentage will drop significantly.
          It would be close but I can’t see the out brigade winning it.

  • Brumanuensis

    A good result in Rotherham. I’m starting to think that UKIP’s results are less of a series of protest votes and more a definite trend, at least in by-elections.

  • NT86

    Good god…have the Lib Dems slumped that much? I know by elections have low turnouts, but before the coalition they generally performed decently, even quite well. Never has there been a party to rise and fall (or shall we say plummet) so quickly as this. The sad thing is that Nick Clegg and some of the really hardcore activists you might find on Lib Dem Voice are so incorrigible at this point, deluding themselves into believing that the party has any real power in this government. How blind do you have to be to not recognise that the coalition is destroying the Lib Dems? It’s sad, because it was always a party I admired during the leadership of Paddy Ashdown and Charles Kennedy. Their councillors in local government have been known to work really hard so it’s a shame how all that promise went to waste.

    In the early to mid 00’s, I thought there was a chance that the party would gradually become the main opposition, given how unpopular the Tories were at the time.

  • David Boothroyd

    Seventh? Er, no, the Liberal Democrats were eighth in Rotherham.

  • Brumanuensis

    The Lib Dems have actually come 8th.

  • NT86

    “does that mean UKIP could be the second (albeit a distant second) party in the North?”

    That’s pretty much what I’ve thought myself. Ever since they performed well at the Barnsley byelection last year. Up north, expect them to supplant the Tories as the main centre right party.

    • Mike Homfray

      Split the Tory vote, we win all the marginals…

  • hindleA

    Weren’t Libdems actually eighth in Rotherham?

  • Brumanuensis

    Croydon North result is superb. Feeling much more cheerful now than at the start of the night.

  • Brumanuensis

    64% is the highest ever share of the vote that Labour have won in Croydon North, even higher than in 1997 and 2001 (the previous peak).

  • Graeme Hancocks

    Thank you, Mark, for bringing us this. Great stuff.

  • Sam Charles Hamad

    Oh what a glorious day for democracy. More Labourite drones/clones elected, who I’m sure will do a wonderful job of repeating Milibland’s slightly watered down Tory mantra (we don’t oppose ConDem austerity, just the timing and pace of it!). I mean, isn’t it a damning indictment of the state of British politics when the leader of the supposed opposition party, never mind one that is *supposed* to be centre-left, has to reproduce the meaningless slogan of a Victorian era Tory? Dismally low turnouts, horrific gains made by the racist, poujadist, little England uber alles, UK Independence Party. The British Democracy in all its glory…

  • Pingback: Congratulations Sarah: now let’s learn the lessons of Rotherham | Left Futures()

  • NT86

    That’s an exceptionally good result in Croydon North. Labour lost quite a bit of ground in London in 2010, but this was a seat where Labour increased its majority even back then.

    As for the worrying rise of protest parties, who are you referring to? Respect completely failed to re-create what happened in Bradford West thankfully, thus showing that victory in March was a fluke. It’s good that Labour are learning not to be complacent about safe seats, but UKIP’s rise needn’t worry the party so much. It’ll probably win more votes than the Tories in northern regions, but crucially can split votes in marginals further south. Let’s face it, politics needs the odd eccentric like Nigel Farage around. He’s a good leader for UKIP.

  • Mike Stallard

    Labour is firmly on track to win the next election thanks to the disastrous coalition and the divided Conservative vote.

  • Pingback: Congratulations Sarah: now let’s learn the lessons of Rotherham « The Landiner()


  • News Dugher criticises Cameron for “ideological sell off” of East Coast ahead of privatisation tomorrow

    Dugher criticises Cameron for “ideological sell off” of East Coast ahead of privatisation tomorrow

    Tomorrow, East Coast Main Line will be taken over by private companies Virgin and Stagecoach.   Ahead of this, Michael Dugher, Shadow Transport Secretary, will give a speech in Leeds in which he’ll outline how Labour would allow public sector companies to “take on lines and challenge the private sector on a genuinely level playing field.” They’d do this, he says, within the first 100 days of government.  . Dugher is expected to say: “The end of East Coast Trains will […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Why we should loudly support Rachel Reeves’ right to maternity leave

    Why we should loudly support Rachel Reeves’ right to maternity leave

    The reactionary howls that greeted Rachel Reeves’ maternity leave plans remind us that, in some quarters, although we have come a long way, there is still just as far to go on when it comes to recognising that (1) women have babies and (2) women can have babies and hold down jobs too. And while we might expect these attitudes in the Conservative party, we shouldn’t be complacent about rooting them out on our side of the political divide either. Of […]

    Read more →
  • Comment An Irish Labour Party activist is proposing a new way forward on Northern Ireland

    An Irish Labour Party activist is proposing a new way forward on Northern Ireland

    The Irish Labour Party will hold their Annual Conference this weekend. One motion in particular is of interest. Motion 94 proposes that the Irish Labour Party organises in Northern Ireland. The idea has been mooted before, but this motion proposes that the party form a joint entity with the UK Labour Party and that members in N. Ireland would be members of both the Irish and UK parties, similar to the National Union of Students/Union of Students in Ireland (NUS/USI) […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Why Labour should welcome health devolution to Manchester

    Why Labour should welcome health devolution to Manchester

    This week’s surprise announcement from George Osborne that £6 billion of health and care spending would be devolved to Greater Manchester has caught Labour (and many in the NHS) off guard. All the details have yet to be agreed, but – based on the revelations in the Manchester Evening News, it is clear the proposals represent a big offer to the northern powerhouse. Whatever the outcome of last year’s Scottish referendum, the result was always going to lead to a political debate about […]

    Read more →
  • Featured 5 reasons why Labour’s tuition fees plan is a big improvement

    5 reasons why Labour’s tuition fees plan is a big improvement

    I was ready to be underwhelmed by Ed Miliband’s tuition fees announcement today. In recent weeks the outlines of Labour’s HE funding policy had been clear, leaving little scope for a ‘big bang’ announcement. And besides, cutting tuition fees to £6,000 didn’t look like a particularly radical reshaping of a system that is quite critically flawed. If the only policy that had been announced today had been a cut in the headline tuition fees figure I’d have been a bit […]

    Read more →
lablist-logo mark-ferguson maya conor coffee-cup
Everything Labour. Every Weekday Morning