Ed Miliband and David Cameron: A Year in review

December 13, 2012 10:00 am

2012 has been a remarkable year in the fortunes of Ed Miliband.

He’s had political and professional successes, But he’s also gone from being “too ugly to be Prime Minister” to being an “unlikely sex symbol”.

OK, a puff piece about a Miliband visit shouldn’t be taken too seriously. But in January, when his leadership was at its lowest ebb, even the Labour supporting Mirror wouldn’t dream of running a headline calling Ed a “Sex symbol” – unlikely or not.

We often ask if politicians and political parties can be “attractive” to voters, but we usually mean in terms of their policies, philosophy and political offer. But the stereotypes that we all bring to public discourse make the qualities we frequently associate (rightly or not) with strong leadership those that are also promoted as sexually attractive in men.

Being viewed as sexy seems to be an important rite of passage for male leaders seeking power. David Cameron was voted among the world’s sexiest men in 2006. Back then he was the next big thing. That proximity to power can be a powerful aphrodisiac – just ask General Petraeus. But as David Cameron becomes inevitably worn down by the difficult job of leading – and seems to be doing that badly, with the latest IPSOS Mori leadership ratings having Ed ahead of him again – he would struggle to chart today.

So what has changed? Well not either man’s physical appearance. But perceptions of them both are changing as – potentially – are their respective career trajectories.

Miliband never had the honeymoon period that new leaders are generally given, and most of the media were convinced both that Labour had chosen the wrong guy and that they would rectify their mistake before the next election. There wasn’t a sense that Ed was a leader to be taken too seriously, and this was reflected constant mocking about his personal style as much as anything else. Nothing was off limits. Caricatures went from “Red Ed” to “Odd Ed”. “Ugly Ed” was probably the nadir.

But his Zen-like approach to politics saw him through the worst, and a much improved performance in 2012 has been the beginning of the making of Ed Miliband – Labour leader. The Party remain comfortably ahead in the polls, and following the Tories disastrous budget have largely closed the gap on trust with the economy – a vital electoral indicator.

Barack Obama just won an election where his polling on the economy was worse than his opponents, but where he scored higher on questions like “is for people like me”. As Cameron and the Tories seem to be doing everything possible to prove they aren’t on the side of ordinary voters, people are looking at Ed with new eyes. His strongest polling has always been for attributes such as “on the side of people like me”. As the tough economy subsides into a long and painful struggle, that dependability can seem very attractive.

In the end, no one is going to win an election based on sex appeal. But the fact that Ed can now – without any more mocking than you’d expect for any politician – be spoken of in such terms shows just how far the Labour leader has come in 2012.

  • AlanGiles

    Emma, If you regard Mr Miliband or Mr Cameron as “sex symbols”, with all due respect, I think you need a drop of bromide in your tea!.

    Clement Atlee, Harold Wilson or Harold McMillian would never have been thought of sex symbols, but they were a damned sight better than today’s little lightweights – of all parties.

    • aracataca

      Including of course privately educated Guardianista Natalie Bennet who, in addition to having a very rich right wing background in Australia, was so lightweight that she didn’t feel able to tell us how many people voted for her as leader in the Green Party’s ‘open and transparent’ leadership election.

    • aracataca

      Including of course privately educated Guardianista Natalie Bennet who, in addition to having a very rich right wing background in Australia, was so lightweight that she didn’t feel able to tell us how many people voted for her as leader in the Green Party’s ‘open and transparent’ leadership election.

    • aracataca

      Including of course privately educated Guardianista Natalie Bennet who, in addition to having a very rich right wing background in Australia, was so lightweight that she didn’t feel able to tell us how many people voted for her as leader in the Green Party’s ‘open and transparent’ leadership election.

  • http://twitter.com/Ceilidhann Kayleigh Anne

    I do find the sex symbol stuff quite funny but I maintain that he’s better looking than his brother. He’s also had less unfortunate banana photo-ops.

    It’s been a good year for Ed, and I think he’s benefited from having so many people underestimate him. The Tory camp are clearly regretting that, as evidenced by their sudden need to get very personal with him, and spend a large portion of their 2012 conference attempting to refute his own speech. One Nation may be a bit of a cheesy slogan but that’s two years in a row the conference season has been defined by his words. He’s also regularly beating Cameron at PMQs (which may be a silly exercise but shows how far he’s come, and exposes Cameron’s inability to defend his record. It’s also a great opportunity to show how Ed is so composed and prepared in comparison to PM’s increasingly shouty and petty performance).

    I hope that in 2013 he keeps up the attacks on the government’s cruel stance on benefits and the disabled. The party’s stance has taken a step in the right direction on this front and I’m hoping it stays that way.

    • aracataca

      imho he has been underestimated throughout his leadership. Keeping quiet for 2 years and enabling the Condems to kill themselves has turned out to be a smart move in retrospect. Even anti-Labour fanatics like Alan Giles and Serbitar have now admitted that there is a strong chance of Labour winning in 2015.

Latest

  • Comment Reforming bus services is an important aspect to revitalising many local economies

    Reforming bus services is an important aspect to revitalising many local economies

    Rail services and infrastructure dominate the debate around transport, but with two thirds of all public transport journeys made by bus we are right to talk more about the importance of local bus services. I serve an area with no rail or light rail link, where many people are entirely dependent on buses. I hear from older residents who are left cut off and isolated, unable to easily access GP or hospital appointments. Shift workers who simply cannot get to […]

    Read more →
  • Comment A rent increase for our Armed Forces tells you all you need to know about David Cameron

    A rent increase for our Armed Forces tells you all you need to know about David Cameron

    This week the Government announced that it would be making changes to accommodation for our service personnel and their families. At first glance you might think that is good news because quite frankly, housing for our service personnel and their families is, at the moment, barely adequate. But what the MoD were actually announcing, hidden under details about a new contract for maintenance, was that our armed forces will now have to pay more in rent to live in accommodation that […]

    Read more →
  • News Scotland Who are the potential candidates for next leader of the Scottish Labour Party?

    Who are the potential candidates for next leader of the Scottish Labour Party?

    Johann Lamont has resigned as leader of the Scottish Labour Party, prompting a new leadership race. As we noted this morning, candidates do not necessarily have to be MSPs, as long as they stand in the Holyrood elections in 2016 – meaning that the next leader could currently be a Westminster MP. So, who are the potential candidates? Here (in alphabetical order) are some of the names that are being mentioned: Douglas Alexander MP: Labour’s Shadow Foreign Secretary and elections […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Scotland Why Lamont left – and what happens next?

    Why Lamont left – and what happens next?

    Johann Lamont’s resignation was a surprise, if only in terms of timing. Politicians – especially party leaders – rarely resign in newspaper interviews released over the weekend. Yet it seems this decision had been coming for a while. This was not something that transpired over a matter of days, but weeks, months or even years (depending on who you speak to). Lamont has made the right decision to step down. She was facing increasing fire both internally and externally, and didn’t […]

    Read more →
  • News Labour “can indeed win”: Blair denies doom-mongering

    Labour “can indeed win”: Blair denies doom-mongering

    The Scottish Labour Party is not the only headache for Ed Miliband this morning. The Telegraph’s front page doesn’t make for the best reading either, running with the news that Tony Blair predicts a Tory victory next year: However, the story is not all it seems. The only quote The Telegraph supplies is from an anonymous source who claims that the former Labour PM made the prediction in a private meeting with them: “The Conservatives will be the next government […]

    Read more →