Labour vs the BBC: Official complaint lodged over Doughty’s on-air resignation

8th January, 2016 7:42 pm


Labour have made an official complaint to the BBC over the handling of Stephen Doughty’s resignation as a shadow minister on Wednesday.

Doughty announced his decision to step down from his role as a Shadow Foreign minister live on the Daily Politics on Wednesday, just minutes before PMQs started. He had spoken to BBC Political Editor Laura Kuenssberg earlier in the day, confirming his plans to resign. Kuenssberg asked if he would make the announcement on the show, which he agreed to. He then wrote to Jeremy Corbyn to tender his resignation before appearing on the programme.

However, the broadcaster has come in for criticism for its actions, and stands accused of “orchestrating” the announcement in order to damage the Labour Party in a biased manner. A senior Labour source told Political Scrapbook: “These events question credibility of all involved … raises questions at the heart of democracy.”

Now Labour have complained to the BBC about the situation. In a statement, a Corbyn spokesperson said:

“By the BBC’s own account, BBC journalists and presenters proposed and secured the resignation of a shadow minister on air in the immediate run-up to Prime Minister’s Questions, apparently to ensure maximum news and political impact. That was evidently done before any notice of resignation was sent to the Labour leader.

“Such orchestration of political controversy is an unacceptable breach of the BBC’s role and statutory obligations.

“Trust in the impartiality and independence of the BBC is essential. The BBC’s role is to report the news impartially, rather than seek to influence events or promote a particular political narrative.”

The complaint is clearly supported by senior Shadow Cabinet ministers such as key Corbyn ally Jon Trickett, who tweeted earlier today that the situation was “a disgrace”.

However, not everyone agrees. Matthew Doyle, a former head of press and broadcasting at the Labour Party, reacted to news of the complaint saying: “Since when has it been wrong for the BBC to break a story? Does Jeremy Corbyn really believe the BBC wouldn’t have done exactly the same thing with an equivalent story from the Tories?”

At the time of writing, an online petition calling for the sacking of Kuenssberg and Daily Politics presenter Andrew Neil had almost 4,000 signatures.

UPDATE: The BBC have responded to the complaint, according to The Times’ Matt Chorley. He has tweeted a reproduction of the email from the Daily Politics’ producer Robbie Gibb to Jeremy Corbyn’s Director of Communications and Strategy Seumas Milne.

Gibb says they did not play “any part in his decision to resign”, and rejects the “suggestion that we orchestrated and stage-managed the resignation of Stephen Doughty”.

He adds that their attempt to “make maximum impact” with their journalism “entirely consistent with the BBC’s Editorial Guidelines and values”.

You can read the whole email here:

UPDATE II: Stephen Doughty says the complaint is a “conspiracy”, that he describes as “embarrassing, embarrassing, embarrassing” (in a reference to this John McDonnell quote) and claims with help the Tories in their attacks on the BBC. Paul Waugh has the quote:

To report anything from the comment section, please e-mail [email protected]


  • Featured News LIVEBLOG: shadow cabinet resignations: Corbyn releases statement

    LIVEBLOG: shadow cabinet resignations: Corbyn releases statement

    Almost a dozen shadow cabinet members have resigned today after Hilary Benn was sacked last night. Corbyn’s decision to bin the Shadow Foreign Secretary came after it was reported Benn was talking to his colleagues about removing Jeremy Corbyn after the EU referendum result. We’ll be bringing you all the shadow cabinet news as it comes through. 22.21 For LabourList’s quick recap of the day, click here. There are rumours swirling around there will further resignations tomorrow which might threaten Corbyn’s ability to fill all positions […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Corbyn issues message of defiance as 11 quit shadow Cabinet

    Corbyn issues message of defiance as 11 quit shadow Cabinet

    Jeremy Corbyn has vowed to stay on as Labour leader and said he will not “betray the trust” of members despite suffering 11 shadow Cabinet resignations in a day. Heidi Alexander led the departures following the sacking of Hilary Benn in the early hours this morning for organising opposition to Corbyn’s leadership. She was joined by Gloria De Piero, Vernon Coaker, Lucy Powell, Seema Malhotra, Ian Murray, Lilian Greenwood, Kerry McCarthy, Charles Falconer, Karl Turner and Chris Bryant, all of […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured The plot to oust Corbyn is anti-democratic and offensive to Labour members

    The plot to oust Corbyn is anti-democratic and offensive to Labour members

    Here in Yorkshire, Labour voters and Labour members have been asking me what on earth some of our Labour MPs are up to. They are telling me that they just don’t understand why, with the Conservative Government up to its neck in trouble, the priority of some Labour MPs appears to be to make divisions in the Parliamentary Labour Party front-page news and engineer a coup against the democratically elected Labour Party Leader. They feel that some Labour MPs are […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured What’s going on with the anti-Corbyn plot?

    What’s going on with the anti-Corbyn plot?

    “You up? Call me, I have a big story for you.” That was the text I received just after one o’clock this morning. Within minutes, it was public that Hilary Benn had been sacked as Shadow Foreign Secretary. That began a chain of events that, since Heidi Alexander’s resignation just after 8am, have moved at some breakneck speed. At the time of writing, eight Shadow Cabinet minister have gone: Hilary Benn, Heidi Alexander, Ian Murray, Seema Malhotra, Kerry McCarthy, Lilian Greenwood, […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Labour is facing “political oblivion” with Corbyn as leader – Labour MPs circulate anti-Corbyn letter to colleagues

    Labour is facing “political oblivion” with Corbyn as leader – Labour MPs circulate anti-Corbyn letter to colleagues

    Margaret Hodge, former minister, and Ann Coffey, MP for Stockport, have said that Labour is looking at “political oblivion” with Jeremy Corbyn as leader, in a letter that has been circulated around the Parliamentary Party. The two Labour MPs submitted a motion of no confidence against Corbyn after they said he didn’t give a clear enough message on the EU referendum. They have hit out at the leader again in a letter (below) and said that Corbyn is “standing in […]

    Read more →

LabourList Daily Email

Everything Labour. Every weekday morning

Share with your friends