Why Labour will oppose the Tory ‘pay more, get less’ plan for councils

11th February, 2016 12:09 pm


The Communities Secretary Greg Clark says he has protected funding for councils over the next four years, but no one left believes him, not even his own MPs.

The Tories’ latest round of cuts takes away £1 in every £3 given to councils to pay for core services. What that means is youth services shut down, streets left unswept, bins emptied less frequently, street lights turned off at night, libraries closed, and rural bus services taken away.  

Even Tory MPs were frightened at how their voters would react once it became clear Osborne’s latest cuts were going to decimate local services.  Even David Cameron’s mum signed a petition against the cuts in Oxfordshire.  With council elections just weeks away across much of the country, the Government came up with a quick fix they hope will buy votes and buy off their rebellious MPs.  

They conjured £300m out of thin air then showered the money over Tory-run councils in some of the wealthiest parts of the country to ease their pain.  Despite the fact that poorer areas, many with Labour councils, have been cut to the bone over the past six years, they get next to nothing.  

If the word gerrymander didn’t already exist we’d have to invent it to describe a fix like that.

It leaves Tory claims to be a ‘one nation’ government looking empty.  Their Northern Powerhouse rhetoric looks more hollow than ever as those councils are left with nothing but yet more cuts.  Leafy Surrey has seen an increase in Government funding over the past five years, yet they’ve been given £24m more.  Meanwhile Liverpool, which has seen funding cut by £400 per person over the past five years, gets more cuts and no help.  It’s the same story in Manchester, Birmingham, Newcastle and so many more who’ve been hit the hardest.  

The Tories hope this multi-million pound sweetener ahead of May’s council elections will buy them votes and buy off their rebellious MPs.  But even this amount of money can’t hide the devastation the Government is wreaking on our communities.

What makes the Tories’ cuts even more painful is they want to hike up council tax at the same time.  Despite an election pledge to keep council tax low, the Government has written to councils telling them to put council tax up by over 20%, costing the average household over £300 more a year.  Instead of helping protect vital local services, that money simply vanishes into the chancellor’s financial black hole.  It still means services will face cuts, with care for older and disabled people hit hardest of all and left with a £1bn funding shortfall.  

People will be paying much more, but it won’t mean their street gets swept more often, their bin emptied more regularly, their library kept open, or their elderly neighbours looked after properly.  Tax payers will pay more but get less in return.

A 20% Tory council tax hike designed in Downing Street, services cut to the bone, and £300million hurled at a handful of wealthy areas in a desperate bid to buy off a bunch of Tory rebels. That is the story of this funding settlement, and is why Labour will voted against it yesterday.

The Tories are desperate to hide the truth ahead of this May’s council elections.  You pay more but get less from this tax-hiking, pledge breaking, self-serving Government.

Steve Reed MP is Shadow Minister for Local Government

To report anything from the comment section, please e-mail [email protected]


  • Featured News LIVEBLOG: shadow cabinet resignations: Corbyn releases statement

    LIVEBLOG: shadow cabinet resignations: Corbyn releases statement

    Almost a dozen shadow cabinet members have resigned today after Hilary Benn was sacked last night. Corbyn’s decision to bin the Shadow Foreign Secretary came after it was reported Benn was talking to his colleagues about removing Jeremy Corbyn after the EU referendum result. We’ll be bringing you all the shadow cabinet news as it comes through. 22.21 For LabourList’s quick recap of the day, click here. There are rumours swirling around there will further resignations tomorrow which might threaten Corbyn’s ability to fill all positions […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Corbyn issues message of defiance as 11 quit shadow Cabinet

    Corbyn issues message of defiance as 11 quit shadow Cabinet

    Jeremy Corbyn has vowed to stay on as Labour leader and said he will not “betray the trust” of members despite suffering 11 shadow Cabinet resignations in a day. Heidi Alexander led the departures following the sacking of Hilary Benn in the early hours this morning for organising opposition to Corbyn’s leadership. She was joined by Gloria De Piero, Vernon Coaker, Lucy Powell, Seema Malhotra, Ian Murray, Lilian Greenwood, Kerry McCarthy, Charles Falconer, Karl Turner and Chris Bryant, all of […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured The plot to oust Corbyn is anti-democratic and offensive to Labour members

    The plot to oust Corbyn is anti-democratic and offensive to Labour members

    Here in Yorkshire, Labour voters and Labour members have been asking me what on earth some of our Labour MPs are up to. They are telling me that they just don’t understand why, with the Conservative Government up to its neck in trouble, the priority of some Labour MPs appears to be to make divisions in the Parliamentary Labour Party front-page news and engineer a coup against the democratically elected Labour Party Leader. They feel that some Labour MPs are […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured What’s going on with the anti-Corbyn plot?

    What’s going on with the anti-Corbyn plot?

    “You up? Call me, I have a big story for you.” That was the text I received just after one o’clock this morning. Within minutes, it was public that Hilary Benn had been sacked as Shadow Foreign Secretary. That began a chain of events that, since Heidi Alexander’s resignation just after 8am, have moved at some breakneck speed. At the time of writing, eight Shadow Cabinet minister have gone: Hilary Benn, Heidi Alexander, Ian Murray, Seema Malhotra, Kerry McCarthy, Lilian Greenwood, […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Labour is facing “political oblivion” with Corbyn as leader – Labour MPs circulate anti-Corbyn letter to colleagues

    Labour is facing “political oblivion” with Corbyn as leader – Labour MPs circulate anti-Corbyn letter to colleagues

    Margaret Hodge, former minister, and Ann Coffey, MP for Stockport, have said that Labour is looking at “political oblivion” with Jeremy Corbyn as leader, in a letter that has been circulated around the Parliamentary Party. The two Labour MPs submitted a motion of no confidence against Corbyn after they said he didn’t give a clear enough message on the EU referendum. They have hit out at the leader again in a letter (below) and said that Corbyn is “standing in […]

    Read more →

LabourList Daily Email

Everything Labour. Every weekday morning

Share with your friends