Don’t trade off bednets and body armour

17th May, 2011 12:12 pm

Liam FoxBy Richard Darlington

Letters from Liam Fox to David Cameron have an uncanny habit of leaking. Last time, the leaked letter was about cuts to the defence budget at the time of the Strategic Defence Review. This time, the letter is about an increase in the international aid budget(£) or rather, as the Defence Secretary’s spokesman told reporters when the news broke last night, “how best to reflect the 0.7% target in law”.

In his last letter, Fox told Cameron that if the SDR “continues on its current trajectory it is likely to have grave political consequences for us, destroying much of the reputation and capital you, and we, have built up in recent years”. For a politician so concerned with his leader’s reputation and political capital, he must realise that adopting the 0.7% target was a key element of Cameron’s detoxification strategy in opposition and the winning of support from NGOs like Save the Children. Given the reputation of the ‘nasty party’, Labour constantly challenged the Tories to prove this commitment. Douglas Alexander’s 2009 DFID White Paper confirmed that Labour would legislate to enshrine the commitment in law in, an announcement made by Gordon Brown in his last party conference speech as Prime Minister. The Lib Dems had no problem welcoming the move but for their detoxification strategy to hold, the Conservatives had to match Labour in their manifesto.

Looking back at page 117 of the Conservative manifesto, the commitment is clear:

“A new Conservative government will be fully committed to achieving, by 2013, the UN target of spending 0.7% of national income as aid. We will stick to the rules laid down by the OECD about what spending counts as aid. We will legislate in the first session of a new Parliament to lock in this level of spending for every year from 2013.”

Liam Fox obviously missed the meeting about this because now he says that his “preferred way ahead” is to put “into statute recognition of the target and a commitment to an annual report against it”. Almost as worrying, he also claims that the OECD rules defining what spending counts as ODA (overseas development aid) will prevent his department raiding the ‘Conflict Pool’ (the fund for peacekeeping and post-conflict reconstruction). He wants to legislate for an annual report (the budget maybe?) in which the government can report that they can’t meet their international commitment to the world’s poorest people and they can’t keep their promise to the voters of Britain.

The last time they were in office, the Conservatives halved the aid budget. Labour trebled it. Aid spending is now 0.59%. In cash terms, the amount at issue here is a rise of £3.9bn, to meet the 0.7% commitment by 2013. Consider this against the Core Defence budget for 2009/10 of £35.4bn and of £36.9 bn for 2010/11, remembering that this does not include operational commitments in Afghanistan or the no-fly zone over Libya.

As well as lifting 3 million people out of poverty every year, building schools and saving the lives of women and children in the poorest countries in the world, much of the international aid budget is spent on upstream conflict prevention. The aid budget is not British taxpayers money that is given away, it is an investment in a safer and more stable world.

Fox’s position will not be unpopular with Tory MPs, as just 4% of them told Conservative Home before the election that international development should be immune from cuts. Perhaps these are the political consequences he is most concerned with. To dog whistle a trade-off between bednets and body armour is not just immoral but also ignores the work that the aid budget does in protecting Britain’s national interests.

Richard Darlington was Special Adviser at DFID 2009-2010 and is now Head of News at ippr

Comments are closed

Latest

  • News Miliband seems likes he wants to win more than Cameron, poll finds

    Miliband seems likes he wants to win more than Cameron, poll finds

    Yesterday David Cameron gave a speech in which he attempted to show his ‘passion’ by saying he’s ‘pumped up’ for the rest of the election campaign. However, prior to this display of election fervour from the Tory camp, YouGov did some polling for The Times Red Box on this very subject. They asked respondents:“of David Cameron and Ed Miliband, which one comes across as wanting to win the most.” Miliband got almost double the amount of votes that Cameron did, […]

    Read more →
  • News Unions Economic growth slows right down as UK sees longest ever fall in living standards

    Economic growth slows right down as UK sees longest ever fall in living standards

    On Sunday, Boris Johnson said “the economy is going gangbusters”. Today, the latest GDP figures show the British economy slowed right down in the first quarter of 2015, to a growth level of just 0.3% – compared to 0.6% in the last quarter of 2014. The only sector where the economy was seen to grow is the service industry, with growth falling in production, construction and agriculture – painting a picture of a highly uneven economy emerging. GDP stats in […]

    Read more →
  • News Tory MP says Cameron has “utterly let down” his constituents

    Tory MP says Cameron has “utterly let down” his constituents

    Tory MP Nick de Bois has accused famous phoney David Cameron of having “utterly let down” his constituents over a hospital closure. Back in 2007, a fresh-faced Tory leader was photographed campaigning to save Chase Farm Hospital. Here he is with de Bois: He even posed with fellow Tory MP – and geography whizz– David Burrowes, holding this poster: Nice pose – remind anyone of anything? In late 2013, both the A&E and maternity services at Chase Farm were closed. So much for no cuts […]

    Read more →
  • News Miliband unveils 10 point plan for action on immigration without “playing the politics of fear”

    Miliband unveils 10 point plan for action on immigration without “playing the politics of fear”

    Yesterday Ed Miliband added a sixth pledge to Labour’s pledge card, when he made further commitments on housing. Today he returns to another of Labour’s pledges – immigration. In a speech in Wales, the Labour leader will challenge David Cameron to back his “clear, credible and concrete” plan for action on immigration in the first 100 days after the election – including an immigration bill in Labour’s first Queen’s Speech. Miliband will say: “Today, I challenge the Conservative Party to […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Seats and Selections Top Tory admits they’ve given up on their No1 target seat

    Top Tory admits they’ve given up on their No1 target seat

    David Cameron is currently running around talking about how “pumped up” he is, and claiming that his party are still aiming for a majority. That would require the Tories to gain more than twenty seats without losing any. To this end, they’ve developed what they call a “40/40″ strategy to try and defend forty seats and win forty seats. The number one seat on their target seat list in Hampstead and Kilburn, where the Tories finished just 42 votes behind […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends










Submit