Don’t trade off bednets and body armour

May 17, 2011 12:12 pm

Liam FoxBy Richard Darlington

Letters from Liam Fox to David Cameron have an uncanny habit of leaking. Last time, the leaked letter was about cuts to the defence budget at the time of the Strategic Defence Review. This time, the letter is about an increase in the international aid budget(£) or rather, as the Defence Secretary’s spokesman told reporters when the news broke last night, “how best to reflect the 0.7% target in law”.

In his last letter, Fox told Cameron that if the SDR “continues on its current trajectory it is likely to have grave political consequences for us, destroying much of the reputation and capital you, and we, have built up in recent years”. For a politician so concerned with his leader’s reputation and political capital, he must realise that adopting the 0.7% target was a key element of Cameron’s detoxification strategy in opposition and the winning of support from NGOs like Save the Children. Given the reputation of the ‘nasty party’, Labour constantly challenged the Tories to prove this commitment. Douglas Alexander’s 2009 DFID White Paper confirmed that Labour would legislate to enshrine the commitment in law in, an announcement made by Gordon Brown in his last party conference speech as Prime Minister. The Lib Dems had no problem welcoming the move but for their detoxification strategy to hold, the Conservatives had to match Labour in their manifesto.

Looking back at page 117 of the Conservative manifesto, the commitment is clear:

“A new Conservative government will be fully committed to achieving, by 2013, the UN target of spending 0.7% of national income as aid. We will stick to the rules laid down by the OECD about what spending counts as aid. We will legislate in the first session of a new Parliament to lock in this level of spending for every year from 2013.”

Liam Fox obviously missed the meeting about this because now he says that his “preferred way ahead” is to put “into statute recognition of the target and a commitment to an annual report against it”. Almost as worrying, he also claims that the OECD rules defining what spending counts as ODA (overseas development aid) will prevent his department raiding the ‘Conflict Pool’ (the fund for peacekeeping and post-conflict reconstruction). He wants to legislate for an annual report (the budget maybe?) in which the government can report that they can’t meet their international commitment to the world’s poorest people and they can’t keep their promise to the voters of Britain.

The last time they were in office, the Conservatives halved the aid budget. Labour trebled it. Aid spending is now 0.59%. In cash terms, the amount at issue here is a rise of £3.9bn, to meet the 0.7% commitment by 2013. Consider this against the Core Defence budget for 2009/10 of £35.4bn and of £36.9 bn for 2010/11, remembering that this does not include operational commitments in Afghanistan or the no-fly zone over Libya.

As well as lifting 3 million people out of poverty every year, building schools and saving the lives of women and children in the poorest countries in the world, much of the international aid budget is spent on upstream conflict prevention. The aid budget is not British taxpayers money that is given away, it is an investment in a safer and more stable world.

Fox’s position will not be unpopular with Tory MPs, as just 4% of them told Conservative Home before the election that international development should be immune from cuts. Perhaps these are the political consequences he is most concerned with. To dog whistle a trade-off between bednets and body armour is not just immoral but also ignores the work that the aid budget does in protecting Britain’s national interests.

Richard Darlington was Special Adviser at DFID 2009-2010 and is now Head of News at ippr

Comments are closed

Latest

  • News Tory ministers urge Osborne to cap rail fare rises

    Tory ministers urge Osborne to cap rail fare rises

    The Evening Standard have reported that high-level Tory minister are pressuring Chancellor George Osborne to cap average rail fare increases next year so that they don’t exceed inflation. In January, fail fares could rise up to nine times more than the average wage increase. It seems many Tories are worried that public discontent over such rapidly rising rail prices could manifest itself at the general election in May. In response, Patrick McLoughlin Secretary of State for Transport will allegedly lobby […]

    Read more →
  • News 300-mile march to protest NHS privatisation sets off tomorrow

    300-mile march to protest NHS privatisation sets off tomorrow

    Tomorrow the People’s March for the NHS will set off  on a 300-mile protest to defend the NHS. The march, organised by a group of women from Darlington (who go by the name of the DarloMums), takes the protestors on same path as that trod by 207 people who took part in the Jarrow March (a protest against high levels of unemployment and poverty in the North East) in 1936. Beginning in Jarrow, the march will cover 300 miles and include 21 […]

    Read more →
  • News Alexander says government must “ensure the Kurds have the military equipment they require”

    Alexander says government must “ensure the Kurds have the military equipment they require”

    As Iraq’s new Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi takes power in Baghdad, the debate moves to what should happen next in Iraq – and in Kurdistan region. Shadow Foreign Secretary Douglas Alexander has released the following statement, in which he alludes to arming the Kurdistan Regional Government to “ensure the Kurds have the military equipment they require”. Here’s the statement in full: “The acceptance of Haider al-Abadi as Iraq’s prime minister-designate potentially offers a new direction. His challenge is now to […]

    Read more →
  • Video Creasy: “Powerlessness is what holds us back”

    Creasy: “Powerlessness is what holds us back”

    Stella Creasy MP for Walthamstow gave an impassioned speech at Twitter HQ last week, where she told the audience that impatience is a virtue and that each of us have to face up to the choices of our generation, not leave it to someone else. She explained “the only thing that really scares me is when people say change isn’t possible…stop worrying – the world isn’t ready and waiting, it’s ready and changing but how is changes…that’s up to you.” Watch […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Scotland The Scottish Referendum: more than a month to go and anything could happen

    The Scottish Referendum: more than a month to go and anything could happen

    Recent polling now has the Labour backed Better Together campaign winning amongst working class voters. That may surprise some people but it’s what I’ve always argued would happen. Working class voters instinctively feel and know that it is them and their neighbours that pay the price for disruptive change. As I go around the country (I’m on my way to my 46th of 100 street corner speeches on Irn-Bru crates) there are always hecklers and as Scotland’s summer has come […]

    Read more →