Don’t believe the Ashcroft spin – the momentum is with Ken

December 8, 2011 3:34 pm

Lord Ashcroft’s poll, published on his website and promoted on Conservative Home today, shows that momentum in outer London is with Ken Livingstone.

Of course, it is being spun differently.

One, it is being presented that Labour should be doing better in the byelection. Labour activists should not be sucked into such ruses. A Labour win in a seat that was so hard-fought in 2010 would be very good news.

Two, the spin aims to show that Boris Johnson is on course for a comfortable victory next May, with the poll showing he is one point ahead of Ken Livingstone. If Ken is not ahead in a Labour seat like this, so the argument goes, he cannot win. Lord Ashcroft writes: “Even in what is about to become a safe Labour seat, Boris is running neck and neck with Ken Livingstone.”

But the poll actually shows the momentum is with Ken, in an outer London seat where Boris Johnson won last time. Ken’s vote is up, and up by more than Boris Johnson’s. In the first poll since Ken announced his seven per cent fares cut, the swing in Feltham and Heston is to Ken Livingstone.

In the last London Mayoral election in 2008, Boris Johnson won 41.9% of the vote, compared to Ken’s 37.5%. This poll shows that the two are now neck and neck in Feltham and Heston: 45% to 44% respectively. That means that Ken has added 6.5% to his vote here, and Boris Johnson 3.1%. So the momentum is more than double in Ken’s favour. Overall, that is a 1.7% swing towards Ken. It means that the mayoral race is narrowing towards eye-wateringly close percentages. It leaves Ken just 1.4% short of the swing across London he needs to seize victory. As we can expect that the Tory surge of 2008 in many parts of London will not be repeated mid-term, it shows not merely that the race is going to be nerve-rackingingly close – but that Labour can clearly win.

Ashcroft may think he has done Boris Johnson a favour, but in fact he has shown that the race is wide open and that the momentum is more with Ken than Boris Johnson.

There are plenty of reasons for Ken’s vote to have risen significantly in Feltham and Heston. Overall crime in the borough of Hounslow is up and police numbers have been cut. The number of young victims of knife crime between has risen 13.69% in Hounslow since Boris Johnson was elected. Under Ken Livingstone every electoral ward in London had a ‘safer neighbourhood’ beat police team with a minimum of six officers patrolling the streets – including one sergeant for each team. Under Boris Johnson eight wards in Hounslow have been forced to share a police sergeant: Hounslow central, Hounslow South, Chiswick Riverside, Chiswick Homefields, Osterley and Isleworth, Bedfont, Feltham North, Heston Central & Heston East. The latter four are all in Feltham and Heston.

And on transport, residents have every reason to swing towards Ken Livingstone. The constituency is in zones five and six. Under Boris Johnson a weekly zone 1-6 travelcard is up one fifth under Boris Johnson – from £44.60 in 2008 to £53.40 this coming January. That makes a local resident £457.6 a year worse off under Boris Johnson. A weekly zones 1-5 travelcard will rise by £2.80 in January, up to £49.80. As with all parts of London a single bus has risen 50% under the Tory mayor.

If Seema Malhotra wins in Feltham and Heston it will show the momentum in London is with Labour – and Ashcroft’s poll shows that in the Mayoral election it is with Ken Livingstone.

Tom Copley is a Labour list candidate for the London Assembly

  • Matt C

    Considering how there was a swing towards Labour in the 2010 General Election and then in the following year the SNP managed to gain a majority and the Kirkcaldy parliament seat, demostrates the capacity of the electorate shifting their. Therefore it is unwise to have a ” post hoc ergo propter hoc” mindset when it comes to elections.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1011867393 Ashley Ubrihien

    Great analysis of the polling!

  • M Cannon

    “Always look on the bright side of life!”.  I would have thought that the interesting aspect of the polling is that Labour’s candidate in the by-election got 52% support, compared with 30% for the Conservative and 10% for the Liberal Democrat.

    But when it came to the mayoral election, the Labour candidate (Mr Livingstone) received only 44% support (8% less than the Parliamentary candidate) and the Conservative candidate (Mr Johnson) 45% (15% more than the Parliamentary candidate).

    I would tentatively suggest that this indicates that either (a) the voters of Feltham and Heston are particularly attracted to Labour’s Parliamentary candidate (or they don’t like the Conservative candidate) or (b) they don’t like Mr Livingstone (or are particularly attracted to Mr Johnson).

    If the answer is (b), then Labour have not chosen their candidate wisely.

    • Redshift

      Erm, Boris is far more popular than the Tories. If the answer is b) Labour could very much have still picked their best candidate. 

      As Tom Copley has pointed out. If Boris won in this part of London in 2008 but now finds himself neck and neck, then it shows that things are moving in Ken’s direction. 

  • flyingtrain

    think you need to go over some references here.

    where for example have you go the information that in 2008 Feltham and Heston voted 

    “Boris Johnson won 41.9% of the vote, compared to Ken’s 37.5%”

    or is this the overall london vote?

    I cannot find a breakdown per parliamentary constituency, but if you have this, please post to back yourself up. 

    If it is the entire london vote (and strangely it is very close to this), this must count as some of the worst analysis and spinning i have ever seen.  To say momentum is with ken going on those figures would be embarrassing.  

    • Bill Lockhart

      Answer came there none.

  • Nick

    There is a breakdown by ward available from the London Elects website, which can be used to calculate constituency results. 

  • Pingback: Politics Live blog: Thursday 15 December | Politics News and Discussion

  • Pingback: Ken Livingstone draws "diving" lines | London-ON.info

  • Pingback: Ken Livingstone draws "diving" lines – Telegraph Blogs

  • Pingback: Ken Livingstone and the true blue rosette - World Bad News : World Bad News

  • Pingback: Ken Livingstone and the true blue rosette - Property Cloud

  • Pingback: Ken Livingstone and the true blue rosette

  • Pingback: Politics Live blog: Thursday 15 December | IGV News Online

Latest

  • News Chris Leslie rules out raising National Insurance to pay for social care

    Chris Leslie rules out raising National Insurance to pay for social care

    The possibility of Labour pledging a specific tax to raise money for NHS spending resurfaced this weekend, with Ed Miliband apparently believing that the NHS is going to be a major issue in 2015. The supposed likely tax rise would be in National Insurance, and this has raised some debate on LabourList this summer, with MP Frank Field supporting the idea, while Andrew Harrop and Adebusuyi Adeyemi have both warned against it. In a revealing interview with Progress magazine, Shadow Chief […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Free School Meals: let’s avoid the sour grapes

    Free School Meals: let’s avoid the sour grapes

    This time last year, the government announced that it would introduce free school meals for all infant school children before the next election. The policy had been endorsed by the School Food Plan commissioned by Gove. It was being championed by the Lib Dems and brought forward so it could be implemented before the 2015 election in what appeared to be a pre-conference deal between the coalition partners. This week 1.5million children in infant schools in England, including my six year […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Weekly survey: Crime commissioners, Douglas Carswell and Labour defections

    Weekly survey: Crime commissioners, Douglas Carswell and Labour defections

    The role of Police and Crime Commissioners (PCCs) has been in the news lately, with the low turnout at the recent West Midlands by-election and the Rotherham abuse scandal becoming focussed on the refusal to quit by the South Yorkshire PCC Shaun Wright. LabourList reported this weekend that Labour are planning to abolish PCCs after the election next year. Should the role be discontinued? Or is there just a better way of making them work? The defection of Douglas Carswell […]

    Read more →
  • Comment It shouldn’t cost so much to be a candidate

    It shouldn’t cost so much to be a candidate

    I love the Labour party. I enjoy canvassing, I pay my subs, go to the various fundraising dinners and vote in National Executive Committee (NEC) elections. I, like many, hate the constant barrage of ‘please donate’ emails and fear the dreaded fundraising call. And if I feel like that, imagine the dread felt by a candidate when they receive such a call. Don’t believe that happens? Hard to believe as it is, on more than one occasion now I have […]

    Read more →
  • News Jim Murphy resumes “100 streets” referendum tour after nationalist abuse

    Jim Murphy resumes “100 streets” referendum tour after nationalist abuse

    Jim Murphy is resuming his soapbox street meetings tour of Scotland tomorrow, after suspending it last week in the face of increasing co-ordinated abuse by supporters of independence. These protests at Murphy’s open-air meetings came to the attention of the media (and the police) when the Shadow Defence Secretary was hit with eggs last week. In a blog for the Spectator this weekend, Murphy explains how the organised groups go beyond the “normal cut and thrust” of politics that the meetings […]

    Read more →