Tony Benn on Margaret Thatcher

April 9, 2013 12:03 pm

There’s a rather poignant piece from Tony Benn on the Margaret Thatcher he knew in today’s Guardian:

“Margaret Thatcher was a very powerful, rightwing force in society. She followed her beliefs and had clear objectives. Her policy was to reverse the trends in modern politics that were made possible by the trade unions being legalised. She decided to eradicate the power of the unions, undermine local government and privatise assets – and these were the three policies of the labour movement.

It was a major attack on democracy and at first it carried some public support, but then it became unstuck, and in the end, it was rejected. But ideas always come back and the modern Tory party is influenced by her ideas.

Although I thought she was wrong, she said what she meant and meant what she said. It was not about style with her; it was substance – I don’t think she listened to spin doctors, she just had a clear idea and followed it through.

I remember her at the funeral of MP Eric Heffer. I was asked to make a speech and as I was waiting, there was someone behind me coughing. It was Mrs Thatcher, and at the end I thanked her for coming and she burst into tears. She had come out of respect for someone whose opinions she disagreed with.”

Both of these politicians are considered to have seen politics (and life) in a black and white way – but this suggests that things are often more complex than that.

  • rekrab

    Looking good TB!!

  • aracataca

    8 million quid of our money is about to be chucked away to pay for her funeral. Harold Wilson (who IMHO was a far better Prime Minister) had an extremely modest funeral with a few friends and family invited to a church service in his beloved Scilly Isles. The ruling class are rubbing our noses in it with this pantomime at public expense.

    • http://twitter.com/renieanjeh Renie Anjeh

      Woah, woah – Harold Wilson was not as transformative as Thatcher, he was not PM for 11 years and he was not the first female PM. She was a huge public figure and politics should not come into it.

    • http://twitter.com/waterwards dave stone

      Well said, mate. They say there’s no money left but millions can be magicked-up out of nowhere if it’s going to be spent on a Tory cause.

      • aracataca

        8 million that can’t be spent on schools or hospitals or welfare of course. It’s sickening.

  • AlanGiles

    If number of election wins should be the arbiter for expensive public funerals, well, yes Mrs Thatcher did win three elections. So did Blair, so we will have to put him down for one when the sad day comes. BUT – Harold Wilson won FOUR:

    October 1964

    March 1966

    February 1974

    October 1974.

    And he chose to resign himself in March 1976, he wasn’t pushed out by his own party.

    Mrs Thatcher was certainly “transformative” – look at the 146 responses (so far) to the article by Messrs Jarvis and Dugher: that isn’t necessarily transformation for the better – just ask people in the North East, Wales, Scotland, Merseyside and so on.

    • AlanGiles

      http://uk.news.yahoo.com/thatcher-funeral-most-brits-oppose-paying-032918420.html#Dth3nco

      I am not saying anything.

      Anything I do say will be taken down and might be revised and used against me in five years time! :-)

    • http://twitter.com/renieanjeh Renie Anjeh

      Didn’t win four consecutively Alan. Thatcher won three elections in a row – that is something. She had a terrible legacy in the North and Jarvis and Dugher are right to raise it. But she did some good things across the world for eg. Falklands, contribution to the end of the Cold War. She also is a Lady of the Garter, first female PM and longest-serving so I think it would be wrong not to give her some sort of public honour, irrespective of her politics. By the way, Wilson decriminalised homosexuality, brought in equal pay for women and brought in rights for ethnic minorities – not your kind of thing.

      • Rudi Affolter

        She made no contribution to the end of the Cold War, she intensified it with her acceptance of US Cruise missiles and purchase of Trident from the US and vocal attacks on so-called communism. The Cold War was ended by the rebellion of the populations of Eastern Europe and Russia. And the work of the peace movement.

  • AlanGiles

    “brought in rights for ethnic minorities – not your kind of thing.”

    Attention seeking again, Mr Anjeh?.

    Be careful you are beginning to revert to your original LL identity. We don’t want that do we?.

    P.S. read any good books lately? :-)

  • Punk Single

    This is a good piece and suggests tolerance is our only way forward not tolerance of greed and inequality but of ideas…

Latest

  • News Video This is how Boris Johnson speaks to those who dare to question him

    This is how Boris Johnson speaks to those who dare to question him

    Earlier this week, the Guardian reported that Boris Johnson was considering 90% funding cuts to youth and education schemes. Understandably, Labour Assembly Members wanted to question the Mayor on this, so Andrew Dismore put him on the spot. Boris did not take it well… This man wants to be Prime Minister. He’ll have to get much better at being scrutinised than this…

    Read more →
  • Comment Unlike under this government, there will be no targets for benefit sanctions under Labour

    Unlike under this government, there will be no targets for benefit sanctions under Labour

    This post is written by Rachel Reeves and Stephen Timms This week’s report from Oxfam, Child Poverty Action Group (CPAG), the Church of England and The Trussell Trust makes shocking reading for anyone who believes our welfare state is there to ensure nobody in our society falls into extreme want or deprivation. The Trussell Trust has previously reported that 913,138 people were given three days emergency food and support in 2013-14 – more than ten times as many as in 2009-10. This […]

    Read more →
  • News London PPCs ask Tories and Lib Dems to support NHS bill tomorrow

    London PPCs ask Tories and Lib Dems to support NHS bill tomorrow

    The private members bill, put forward by Clive Efford, which hopes to “halt the rush to privatisation and put patients rather than profits at the heart of our NHS” will be voted on by MPs tomorrow in the House of Commons. Ahead of this vote, the 38 Labour parliamentary candidates in London seats  have written an open letter (the full text of which can be found below) asking the Tory and Lib Dem MPs holding the seats they’re hoping to […]

    Read more →
  • News Proof (if any were needed) that UKIP could cost Labour seats that we need to win

    Proof (if any were needed) that UKIP could cost Labour seats that we need to win

    Stockton South is No.7 on Labour’s target seat list. It was won in 2010 by only 332 votes, by the youngest Tory in Parliament (James Wharton). And it’s one of only two Tory seats in the North-East, a Labour stronghold. And yet a poll from Survation (commissioned by Unite) suggests that the Tories may hold onto the seat, and that Labour’s vote may actually have gone down since 2010. Clearly failing to win such a seat – a top 10 target […]

    Read more →
  • Comment We need to talk about domestic violence – now

    We need to talk about domestic violence – now

    We need to talk about domestic violence. We need to talk about it now, because austerity is making the problem worse. There was a sharp leap in domestic violence in the last quarter of 2013 – with a rise of 15.5% of victims suffering abuse at home. We don’t know whether that’s because of increased reporting or increased offending, because domestic violence is shrouded in secrecy. What we do know is that – because of cuts to funding – 103 […]

    Read more →