Shadow Minister resigns from Labour front bench over Syria vote

August 29, 2013 8:56 pm

Rumours have been circulating in the last hour that Shadow Transport Minister Jim Fitzpatrick was resigning over Labour’s stance of Syria. That has now been confirmed.

A Labour source told LabourList in the last few minutes:

“Jim Fitzpatrick has tonight handed in his resignation as Shadow Transport Spokesman.”

In his Commons speech today Fitzpatrick argued that the Labour amendment on Syria is better than Government motion but is still too open to idea of future military action. He said he’d be voting against both, so a resignation is inevitable. He said:

“I have problems – for the honourable gentleman’s information – both with the Government motion and the Opposition amendment. I do not believe either is ultimately able to achieve the honourable ends that both sides of this house are trying to achieve. I’m opposed to military intervention in Syria, full stop. And to be honest with myself, and to be consistent on both questions, I will be voting in the ‘no’ lobby against the Government motion and against the Opposition amendment.”

(H/t: Coffee House)

More on this as we get it.

  • whs1954

    Let’s face it – Fitzpatrick hasn’t resigned because he really gives a stuff about Syria. He has a constituency full of Muslims, fought George Galloway at the last election, and has a particularly nasty Bengali nationalist/Islamist mob running his council and potentially challenging him for his seat next time. He’s resigned to burnish his anti-war, pro-Islamist credentials with those who will be asked to re-elect him. As for those being massacred in Syria, why should he give a stuff, they don’t have votes in Poplar & Canning Town.

    • Afzal

      @whs1954:disqus That is a load of rubbish. He voted for the war in Iraq and beat George Galloway at the last election. What were all the one dimensional Muslims doing then?

      As for Bengali nationalists running the council? Shows how much you know.

  • crosland

    Well that’s ok. He’s being honest and apart from being used a bit by the media, is better that remaining in a shadow post if he doesn’t accept the collective leadership position.

    Far more honest than this crowd;

    http://www.libdemvoice.org/syria-lib-dem-members-poll-35939.html

  • crosland

    Perhaps Diane is next ?

    • Mike Homfray

      I think she said she could live with the delay tactic.

      • ColinAdkins

        Abbott and principle are contradictions in terms.

  • Pingback: Obama’s Middle East ‘Oh! Mama!’ Moment | हिन्दू तर्क शास्त्रद्न्य सिद्धार्थ

  • crosland

    The afore mentioned may well be true, I don’t live around there. However, assuming that is the sole motivation may not be accurate.
    Interesting isn’t it that those without any non-indigenous population in their constituency can wave the flag on this issue, while the Arab League is sitting on its backside (aside from suspending Syria from membership) and objecting to armed intervention, but certain members of it are still content for the USA and UK to go into Syria ? Why not let them sort it in their own region ?
    Time the Saudi’s got their hands mucky instead of pilots from the UK etc perhaps ? It’s not as if these states don’t have aircraft is it ?

  • Pingback: Not a clear-eye in the house | Better Left Unsaid

  • NT86

    But what type of Muslims live in Poplar and Canning Town? Are they Sunni or Shia? Some of those in the former category would have supported action since Assad isn’t a Sunni himself and Islam has its own tribal/sectarian divisions.

    Also you do realise that Islamists make up a huge proportion of the opposition in Syria. Supplied by Saudi and Qatar.

  • Mike Homfray

    I think it was tactical and Ed should offer him the option to stay -but as he’s almost definitely going to be a likely victim of re shuffling…

  • RogerMcC

    ‘constituency full of Muslims’?

    The only two constituencies with over (and only just over) 50% Muslim populations are Birmingham Hodge Hill and Bradford West.

    Poplar and Limehouse (the actual name from 2010 of Fitzpatrick’s seat) has a 33% Muslim population which makes them important – but not so important that Fitzpatrick can expect to lose his seat over one vote that displeases them.

    Indeed when Fitzpatrick was up against George Galloway the Dundee Jihadist only got 17.5% of the vote on a 62% turnout so it is unlikely that more than a third even of Muslim electors voted for him.

    And why is it axiomatic that all Muslims violently oppose intervention in Syria?

    We are after all constantly being told that the opposition to Assad is Islamist if not entirely made up of al-Qaeda members (an interesting Orwellian inversion of the normal far left line which used to attack every one making any such statement as ‘Islamophobic’ and which I think deserves a lot more comment).

    So why would the predominantly Sunni Muslims of the East End support a murderous secularist regime controlled by the Alawite sect that even most of the orthodox Twelver Shi’ites that Sunnis see as heretics regard as nothing better than pagans?

    And in fact this is what the Muslim Association of Britain has to say about Syria:

    We call on all activists and workers to support the revolution in every field and arena, everywhere; and to pressurise the political establishments to take firm action against the tyrannical Asad regime.

    So stop labelling whole diverse London constituencies as ‘Muslim’ and all British Muslims as anti-western fanatics.

  • RogerMcC

    Click on his name and look at where he normally comments and what he normally says – he even signs one comment at the Telegraph ‘A Tory’.

    In other words a troll.

  • JoaniReid

    Although I disagree, I have far more respect for this stance, that is one of conviction than the politically convenient one held by the others.

  • DoctorZoidburg

    Well done stick to your principles hopefully there will be more like him VIVA ukip;

  • MrSauce

    Good to see a politician standing up for what he believes is right.
    Shame it is so very rare.

  • Pingback: Why Rushanara Ali has quit Labour’s front bench: The threat of Lutfur Rahman’s Rabina Khan | Trial by Jeory

Latest

  • Comment 5 things that Labour can learn from feminism

    5 things that Labour can learn from feminism

    This post is written by Anya Pearson and Rosie Rogers From UK Feminista, Daughters of Eve to No More Page 3, the new wave of feminism sweeping Britain has left party politics looking beached in comparison. One in four women have answered that they don’t know which party they will vote for in 2015 or else won’t be voting at all, trust in politicians is at an all-time low and policy struggles to offer inspiring solutions to the challenges people face in their daily […]

    Read more →
  • Comment PMQs verdict: No apology is good enough. Freud must go, and he must go today

    PMQs verdict: No apology is good enough. Freud must go, and he must go today

    PMQs returns, and the Labour Party had an ambush waiting for Cameron. A recording from Lord Freud – the despicable welfare minister – saying that disabled people don’t deserve the full minimum wage (and suggesting that they might be paid £2 an hour) dropped only moments before PMQs. Ed Miliband – throat scratching as he delivered his lines without the aid of his voice – croaked as he spoke to the Commons. Yet the strained voice, painful as it sounded, actually seemed […]

    Read more →
  • News Lord Freud’s apology “not the end of the matter”, say Labour

    Lord Freud’s apology “not the end of the matter”, say Labour

    Lord Freud has apologised for his comments suggesting that disabled people are “not worth” the minimum wage. After Miliband raised the comments at PMQs today, the minister in charge of welfare reform, which includes the introduction of the Bedroom Tax, issued a retraction: “I would like to offer a full and unreserved apology. I was foolish to accept the premise of the question. To be clear, all disabled people should be paid at least the minimum wage, without exception, and […]

    Read more →
  • News Sadiq Khan to head up Labour’s anti-Green Party strategy

    Sadiq Khan to head up Labour’s anti-Green Party strategy

    Sadiq Khan has been given a new role in Labour’s election campaign, running a unit charged with dealing with the threat from the Green Party over the next seven months. The New Statesman’s George Eaton reveals that Khan has been handed the job by election co-ordinator Douglas Alexander. The Tooting MP’s previous stint as chair of Liberty, the civil liberties campaign organisation, means he is widely considered as well-placed to recapture socially liberal voters lost during the New Labour years. […]

    Read more →
  • Featured David Cameron’s government: some disabled people are “not worth the full wage” 

    David Cameron’s government: some disabled people are “not worth the full wage” 

    David Cameron’s welfare supremo has advocated treating those most in need differently by paying them below the national minimum wage. Lord David Freud, speaking at a fringe event at  Conservative Party Conference, said he thought there was “a group” of disabled people who are “not worth the full wage”. Lord Freud has exposed a face of the Conservative Party which sees the vulnerable as runners up, those in need as undeserving, and the minimum wage as applying just to a few of […]

    Read more →
7ads6x98y