Shadow cabinet reshuffle liveblog

May 15, 2012 10:20 pm

22.31 – A couple of shadow ministerial changes (not cabinet) to tell you about. In addition to Tom Harris going to DEFRA, Catherine McKinnell will be joining the Treasury team (replacing Owen Smith) and Lisa Nandy joins the Education team.

If there are more sub cabinet roles reshuffled, we’ll start another liveblog to catalogue them. Lucky you.

16.54 – So Cruddas is now Labour’s full-time in-house policy thinker. Liam Byrne remains in the DWP brief (albeit after a great deal of speculation that has weakened his position). Owen Smith joins the Shadow Cabinet. And Lord Adonis will be taking on an industrial Strategy role. And last, but very much not least, Angela Eagle will Chair the NPF.

Full analysis coming up – but thanks for sticking with us through this (admittedly long) reshuffle liveblog.

16.45 – Reshuffle in full. The Party have just announced:

Jon Cruddas is to become Coordinator of the Labour Party Policy Review.

Ed Miliband will recommend to the National Policy Forum that Angela Eagle becomes its new chair.

Owen Smith is to replace Peter Hain as Shadow Secretary of State for Wales.

Andrew Adonis will advise the Policy Review on areas of Labour’s industrial strategy.

16.30 – Amber Elliot from Total Politics suggests that Lord Adonis was considered for the policy review role (he was a former head of the No 10 policy unit) but Cruddas pipped him to the role.

16.18 – So if Owen Smith is promoted, the Treasury team will need a new face. And no word on Liam Byrne’s DWP role yet. Looks like he’s gone from the policy review – but since there’s no chatter about DWP, is he still in the shadow cabinet?

16.15 – James has also heard Angela Eagle will chair the NPF. Would make sense if true, she’s widely respected across the party, smart and won’t ruffle too many feathers.

16.12 – According to James Lyons of the Mirror – Jon Cruddas has got the policy review. We said yesterday he was interested in making a return.

16.02 – Tom Harris will be back on the frontbench I’m told – going to be part of the shadow DEFRA team.

15.58 – We expect the full result in an hour, but Owen Smith looks almost certain to be shadow Welsh secretary.

14.56 – The BBC have made their own list of MPs who might replace Peter Hain. Alongside the names we’ve already mentioned, they’ve included Wayne David, Huw Irranca-Davies and Nia Griffith – all of whom would be in with a shout.

14.02 – Not much happening on the reshuffle yet. Or as one hack said to me this afternoon – this is putting the shuffle in reshuffle. Groan.

13.39 – Plenty of people contacting me since in mentioned Owen Smith. He’s clearly a man with fans. Keep an eye on him.

12.22 – A few people have asked in the last 24 hours why I didn’t have Owen Smith down as one of the favourites to replace Hain as Shadow Welsh Secretary. He’s a big talent, and someone I expect to become a big player in the future, but right now he’s at the heart of the action in the shadow Treasury team. I’d be surprised to see him moved from there.

11.15 – Quick round up of the ShadCab reshuffle news in today’s papers before we move on. The Times (£) has urged Ed M to bring back his brother (unlikely, as I said yesterday) alongside Andrew Adonis and Alistair Darling. The FT have talked about Ed Miliband now being more secure than he was before, yet seemingly before he was like a man walking across a ship with a Ming vase. Faint praise then. The FT also suggest that David Miliband was offered the Shadow Chancellor job back in January 2011 (post Alan Johnson). That’s something that has been whispered around Westminster before – but I’m not sure anyone had ever gone to press with it before.

Meanwhile in the Indy, the briefing has begun from the friends of Liam Byrne warning Miliband that removing him would be a return to factionalism. That’s one reason why I’d be surprised to see Byrne leave unless he were replaced by someone from the same wing of the party. A promotion for Liz Kendall perhaps?

11.02 – Morning everyone. Ed Miliband is speaking to the Royal College of Nursing this morning, and we’re expecting that the reshuffle will be finalised and confirmed (in an orderly fashion) this afternoon (or tomorrow morning at the latest). Some within the party are beginning to worry that this reshuffle is “dragging on” and that the sword of Damocles can only hang over the heads of certain individuals for so long before they take matters into their own hands. Yet Ed’s team have learned the lessons of last time, and are trying to avoid the drip drip drip of information about the reshuffle leaking out. More’s the pity. I’ll still be bringing you everything I hear though – both confirmed, and unconfirmed.

————

18.38 – A few Shadow Cabinet members we can confirm already (from the Lords). Jan Royall, Steve Bassam and Phil Hunt remain Opposition Leader, Opposition Chief Whip and Opposition Deputy Leader respectively in the Lords. Both Royall and Bassam sit in the shadow cabinet – and their positions were confirmed (as was Hunt’s) when they were re-elected unopposed by Labour Peers today.That support is in no small part down to the battles they’ve led in the Lords through the first two years of the Coalition, especially in the past six months with the welfare, legal aid and health bills.

It’s also believed that Hunt will replace Glenys Thornton as Labour’s Health Spokesperson in the Lords.

16.16 – More on that Lords reshuffle (09.12). We understand Glenys Thornton will be moving from Health to the equalities brief.

12.13 – We’ll be continuing with the liveblog as long as it takes, but don’t expect any announcements today. Ed Miliband is addressing the Royal College of Nursing tomorrow. We understand there’ll be no reshuffle news under after that – so Tuesday afternoon or Wednesday morning it is…

11.41 – It was confirmed this morning (and fired the starting pistol on the reshuffle) that Peter Hain is stepping down. He has been a loyal and trusted ally of Ed Miliband since the earliest days of his leadership, and has done some heavy lifting that others weren’t keen on doing (Refounding Labour anyone?). Ed Miliband has paid tribute to him, and quite right, Hain has had a remarkable career.

11.27 – This is the first reshuffle in years that hasn’t featured speculation about Jon Cruddas heading onto the front bench. Let me rectify that oversight – and the Dagenham MP might now be coming around to the idea. We know he’d consider a tilt at London Mayor – but could the front bench also be in his sights? Maybe not this time, but his reservations about Ed M have subsided in recent months – so perhaps next time?

11.00 – Every reshuffle that comes around inevitably brings around the rumour that Tessa Jowell will be leaving the shadow cabinet. Let’s knock this one on the head. The Olympics are just a few months away. Jowell is the Shadow Olympics Minister and played a big role in securing the London Games. She’s not going anywhere.

09.12 – As well as a reshuffle in the commons, expect to see some rotating of roles amongst Labour’s front bench in the Lords today too. Willy Bach looks set to step down from his justice role (with an impressive 14 Tory defeats to his name) and will be replaced by Jeremy Beecham.

08.35 – So who will replace Hain in the Shadow Wales portfolio? The two most widely tipped so far are the witty Kevin Brennan and the phone hacking veteran Chris Bryant. Both good parliamentary performers – both sound potential promotions.

08.10 – One or two papers over the weekend even tried to suggest that a return for David Miliband was in the offing. Although I wish that were true, it seems highly unlikely, considering just six days he wrote an article for the Mirror on why he was spending his time “on the front line not the front bench”. Not even Cameron makes u-turns that quickly.

08.05 – The other major rumour being kicked about revolves around Liam Byrne. Could he lose his policy brief, his shadow DWP brief, or even his position in the shadow cabinet altogether? I’ve already looked at this in more detail.

08.00 – Today looks likely to be the day when reshuffle speculation reaches a crescendo, so welcome to our latest shadow cabinet reshuffle liveblog, where we’ll be bringing you all of the rumours about changes in the top team – before separating fact from fiction.

The one change we are absolutely certain will take place is Peter Hain leaving the shadow cabinet as Shadow Welsh Secretary. Hain confirmed this on BBC Wales this morning, but we can also confirm that Hain will be stepping down as Chair of Labour’s National Policy Forum.

  • AlanGiles

    …and I have to be out most of the day :-(

    Still, I am sure, for many on LL, including myself, one word is on everyone’s lips. It’s not a very nice word, but it does describe Mr Byrne.

    ………

    New link coming up: all yesterdays and first thing today were trombonists

    * Don Joseph (1923  -     )

  • Dave Postles

    I hope that we can express a sincere vote of gratitude to Peter Hain for his entire career, from anti-apartheid onwards.  Good luck to him.

    • treborc1

      I suspect a few will moan about him, I remember him  going way back when he first came onto the political scene. His battles with apartheid the marches the speeches, I suspect he’s not had  that much to do of late in the real political world, and of course he’s losing his seat with the boundary changes and would need to fight a new seat somewhere , I suspect he will retire at the next election to move onto something else in the media I suspect.

      • treborc1

         Why are comments moving around the place

  • Guest

    re 08.35 –  word from Welsh media (Radio Wales, Western Mail etc) is Owen Smith is favourite at the mo…

  • hp

    The tricky part will be shuffling-out everyone that had a part in the economic mess the UK was left in while retaining enough familiar faces to be recognisable as the Labour SC.
    This won’t be done all at once, I think a series of shuffles

  • AlanGiles

    Well, talk about a damp squib!. But I wouldn’t hold my breath for Cruddas to  run for Mayor – he bottled out of accepting a minor post when he did so well in the deputy leadership election, so I wouldn’t entrust him with the Mayoral post. He would probably change his mind and back out a few weeks before the 2016 election.

    I am sure Mark will be delighted that Ed Miliband seems to be erring on the side of caution where the reshuffle is concerned, but frankly, it looks a bit timorous, all trailer and no big picture you might say.

    I understand Byrne has told EM that he wants to stay in post. Without wishing to do a “Guy” anyone who has ever employed anybody will know that when they start looking down the situations vacant column, they are losing interest, and when they get to the point of telling you they are actively seeking another position, that is the time you suggest to them it is time they handed in their notice, it is just unsettling for everybody.

    * Joe Newman (1922-1992)

    • Chilbaldi

      Agreed re Cruddas. He’s a funny one. I’d compare him to a striker who doesn’t like taking penalties – a politician who shies away from any job that requires being practical as opposed to theorising.

      • Daniel Speight

         Like a reluctant messiah, he doesn’t seem to want to lead. It’s really too late now. When we needed him he wasn’t there.

    • http://twitter.com/robertsjonathan Jonathan Roberts

      I think it’s a tricky one for Ed this.  A reshuffle is forced by Hain’s resignation, which gives him a good opportunity to play around a little.  But he is doing well in the polls and he needs to not disturb the momentum too much – a reshuffle is usually a way of refreshing and reviving, none of which is needed at a time of apparently strong public approval (or at least a public sympathy towards his direction).

      • AlanGiles

        I think, Jon, now is the best time to wield the axe – while the momentum is with him. The polls could change again next month, so while the party is in such good heart – or at least  the sniping from certain quarters has stopped. From a personal point of view, Ed is still not out of the woods – just not so unpopular as Cameron and given Brooks and the news this afternoon that A4E has been naughty and lost one of their contracts, Cameron should remain on the ropes – but I really feel Byrne has to go, and Ivan Lewis as well. Someimes you have to be ruthless, and be cruel to be kind (though in the case of LB I would be cruel to be cruel!.
        A pity Peter Hain has gone, since he was more representitive of what I would call traditional Labour.* Don Lusher (1923-2006)

  • Mario Dunn

    You are trying to get blood from a stone here

  • LabourtillIdie

    Jon Cruddas – Defeat from the jaws of victory

  • Mario Dunn

    Well that was exciting – well worth it…

  • Mark

    Cruddas is a real odd-ball. Despite preaching Christian compassion as far as welfare goes he is a close personal friend of James Purnell – the two almost seemed to be a double-act so many time did they appear on the same platform together giving talks – and supported Purnell’s welfare reforms wholeheartedly apart from one occasion when he voted for an amendment to the bill designed to prevent single-parents from being stripped of their benefits if they couldn’t take up an offer of work immediately. He was also, like his pal Purnell, one of the most expensive MPs in the House of Commons, making lavish claims for reimbursement for all manner of things big and small. Despite being quite an outspoken individual when people looked to him to offer himself for consideration for a leadership role he shied away and stepped back into the shadows in a surprisingly cowardly manner for a man of convictions.

    To be honest I think Cruddas is a paper tiger.

    But the worst thing of all about this faux-reshuffle is that Liam Byrne remains at the DWP.

    Shame.

  • Brumanuensis

    Pleased that Cruddas is on board – remember it was him who angrily asked David Miliband (of Ed) ‘why don’t you just punch him’. Nonetheless, Cruddas is smart man and has a number of interesting ideas, even if like Mark I’m a bit put out by his closeness to Purnell.

    Owen Smith is a good choice too. Not so pleased with Tom Harris getting a front-bench role and it’s a shame Byrne hasn’t got the chop, given his palpable lack of enthusiasm for staying in the Shadow Cabinet.

  • Robert_Crosby

    I hope Cruddas vindicates the thinking of those of us who have long hoped for him to have more influence at the top of the Party.  I suspect that voters may be more inclined to identify with him than the likes of Balls, Cooper or David Miliband.

    Marginalising Byrne is a good thing and hopefully he will off the front bench for good before long.

  • treborc1

    Here is a bit that I like….

     http://www.compassonline.org.uk/news/item.asp?n=11852

  • derek

    Harris the knife has popped out from around the corner! Jeez! I need a bit of inspiration.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p7yxOOa8ofc&feature=related 

  • Mr Chippy

    Industrial policy – Adonis. Sad reflection on the decline of the influence of trade unions. Adonis has always impressed me whilst not agreeing with his politics but he appears more hand off than hands on.

  • Bill Lockhart

    I am delighted that Liam Byrne will continue to shadow IDS and think the unthinkable about welfare reform. He is a fine man who believes in capitalism, private enterprise, and self-reliance. Crack down on the poor a bit and that’ll get them to shift themselves and make successes of their lives more than benefits and mercy. Hardship is the best instructor. No more of this bleeding heart love-doevy stuff. Crack the whip. That’s the way to go. Crack the whip and the cat-o-nine-tails frequently and hard.

  • Bill Lockhart

    Some pitiful coward is stealing my name again. Says a hell of a lot more about him than it does me.

  • ThePurpleBooker

    I’m a bit upset that Ed’s reshuffle did not go as far enough as it could have. The appointment of Jon Cruddas is extremely welcome, and promoting Owen Smith was a very good move but there could have been more Ed could have done. Firstly, he could have removed Rosie Winterton from the shadow cabinet, and made Angela Eagle chief whip (but she remains Chair of the NPF) and then he could have made Douglas Alexander the shadow leader of the house of commons. Then the person he should have replaced with Douglas Alexander could have been David Miliband.
    Secondly, he should have sacked Jon Trickett and replaced him with Stella Creasy, and then he could have replaced Stella Creasy with Bridget Phillipson. Thirdly, he should have also removed Tom Watson from the shadow cabinet, so that he could concentrate on opposing Murdoch in the select committee, by making Douglas Alexander the election co-ordinator and then making Jon Cruddas the Labour Party Deputy Chair. Fourthly, he should have moved Sadiq Khan to Shadow Attorney General, then he could have made Emily Thornberry the Shadow Minister for Women and Equalities and then he could have made made Harriet Harman Shadow Justice Secretary so that he could bring in Chirs Bryant as Shadow Culture Secretary, and then he could have replaced Bryant with Jack Dromey who could have been replaced with Jonathan Reynolds who could have been replaced by Michael Dugher (who could also become a whip) and then he could have made Tristram Hunt his Shadow Minister without Portfolio. Fifthly, he should have removed Jan Royall and then put Lord Wood of Anfield there so that he could make Andrew Adonis the shadow minister without portfolio. That way he would have cut the size of the shadow cabinet but also he would have brought in all the useful talents he needed. The changes already made are welcome, there was more that he should have done.

  • Pingback: Adonis: There’s a “state of warfare” between Number 10 and Whitehall | Left Foot Forward

Latest

  • News Unison Conference 2013 Unison set out their expectations for a Labour government

    Unison set out their expectations for a Labour government

    Unison General Secretary Dave Prentis set out his tests for continuing to support Labour this afternoon. Speaking at their conference in Liverpool, Prentis said: For too long we’ve built the careers of Labour politicians, only to be let down when we needed them most. I don’t want to hear Labour apologising for past mistakes, I want to see a clear agenda from Labour for the future. We must not support a Labour Government that does not : put an end [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Scotland Why on earth shouldn’t Nigel Farage visit Scotland?

    Why on earth shouldn’t Nigel Farage visit Scotland?

    You’ve got to admire Nigel Farage. Like a comedian who’s already died on stage at the Glasgow Empire, he’s put on his “optimistic” hat and chosen to return to Scotland to campaign for UKIP. His last visit, you will recall, was memorable for his being forced to seek refuge in an Edinburgh pub from a mob of nationalists and trots shouting “SCUM!” at him as he tried to convey his message (a tad harsh, I thought. But I suppose “gentleman [...]

    Read more →
  • Comment

    Labour needs more than a few warm words on the environment, energy security and climate change

    It seems that with the announcements of their intention to end universality in social security and accept the Coalition’s spending envelopes, Labour are gradually beginning to articulate what the Labour Party’s 2015 manifesto will look like. While much has been said on social security, general economic direction and housing shortages; there has been little said on the environment, energy security and climate change. Other than a few warm words from Mary Creagh MP in LabourList’s ‘One Nation Labour: Debating the Future’ [...]

    Read more →
  • News 5,000 soldiers face redundancy – Media roundup: June 18th, 2013

    5,000 soldiers face redundancy – Media roundup: June 18th, 2013

    Subscribers to our morning email get the best of LabourList – including the Media and blog round up – every weekday morning. If you were a subscriber you would have already received this (and much more) in your inbox. You can sign up here. 5,000 soldiers face redundancy Thousands of members of the armed forces will receive redundancy letters tomorrow – as Government defence cuts continue to bite. Up to 5,300 serving soldiers in the Army will lose their jobs – including [...]

    Read more →
  • News Has David Cameron lost the plot?

    Has David Cameron lost the plot?

    Once upon a time David Cameron was known for his deft handling of the public mood. Not anymore. Last night, he tweeted: This is the menu for the #G8UK dinner. I’ll chair a discussion on tax, trade, transparency and Syria at 830 tonight pic.twitter.com/GAWDxvEDkI — David Cameron (@David_Cameron) June 17, 2013 This is a Prime Minister who is often lambasted as “out of touch”, at a time when half a million people are being driven to using Foodbanks because they [...]

    Read more →